stratechery
stratechery

Apple Rejects Google Now; EU to Investigate

Google today announced via their blog that they are filing a complaint with the Justice Department and EU regarding Apple’s recent rejection of Google Now for iOS.

“It’s clear that Apple is leveraging its OS monopoly to ensure Siri is the leading personal assistant software,” said Kent Walker, Senior Vice President and General Counsel at Google. “We applaud innovation and recognize that Apple has earned its dominance in smartphones, but that does not give them the right to abuse that dominance to eliminate competition in services.”

The iPhone, which was launched in 2007, is on 70% of the world’s smartphones, and 35% of all phones worldwide. Microsoft is in a distant second place, with less than 10% of the smartphone market. Much of the iPhone’s dominance can be traced to its app store, with over 800,000 apps; Microsoft’s equivalent store has less than 100,000, and most industry observers say its apps are of much lower quality.

“Had there been a competitive OS before 2011 (when Windows Phone 7 became widely available), there may have been room for a duopoly,” said analyst Bob Beginerle. “But iOS simply had too much momentum.”

Apple has received criticism that its services, such as mail, maps, calendaring, and messaging are inferior to those of Google, Facebook, and even Microsoft, but most experts think it’s only a matter of time until iCloud, the name for their collection of services, has more market share than any of its competitors.

“Because Apple has the final say on what runs on their operating system, most customers simply default to iCloud services, including Siri,” said blogger Ben Thompson. “What has to really worry Google is if Apple bans alternative ad networks as well.”


In 2011, Bill Gurley wrote The Freight Train That is Android:

AdWords is an highly respectable castle, and Google would clearly want to put a “unbreachable moat” around it. Warren himself is on record suggesting that Google’s moat is pretty good already. But where could you extend the moat? What are the potential threats to Google’s castle? Basically, any product that stands between the user and Google…

So here is the kicker. Android, as well as Chrome and Chrome OS for that matter, are not “products” in the classic business sense. They have no plan to become their own “economic castles.” Rather they are very expensive and very aggressive “moats,” funded by the height and magnitude of Google’s castle. Google’s aim is defensive not offensive. They are not trying to make a profit on Android or Chrome. They want to take any layer that lives between themselves and the consumer and make it free (or even less than free). Because these layers are basically software products with no variable costs, this is a very viable defensive strategy. In essence, they are not just building a moat; Google is also scorching the earth for 250 miles around the outside of the castle to ensure no one can approach it. And best I can tell, they are doing a damn good job of it.

The alternate reality depicted above is the reality of a world without Android. Given enough time without viable competition, it is very reasonable to believe that iOS would have gained a natural monopoly in smart phones,1 just as Microsoft once did in PCs. And in a monopoly, one serves at the pleasure of the king.

The fact Google is able to compete on iOS is evidence enough that Android is a wild success. Apple needs to allow Google’s services; if they didn’t, they would risk competition on the services layer vis a vis Android, and offer customers a valid reason for leaving iOS. Or, to put it another way, if Android didn’t exist, it wouldn’t matter how much iCloud sucked.

Google wins, whether or not Android wins.2 Winning is in the eye of the beholder.3

UPDATE: See the follow-up article, If Not for Android, Where Would Google Be?.

  1. Although every player in mobile, including the carriers, would have fought this result tooth-and-nail. I leave it as a thought experiment to the reader to consider what this says about the reasons Android has been successful
  2. And to be fair to Tom, we actually mostly agree on this count
  3. Android serves other purposes as well: it gets more people online, which flows directly to Google’s bottom line, and it gives valuable signaling data to Google’s data engine.

157 thoughts on “Apple Rejects Google Now; EU to Investigate

  1. Pingback: lock smith

  2. Pingback: Go Karts Go Turbo Online

  3. Pingback: content

  4. Pingback: Dentist Peoria Az

  5. Pingback: audio PA rental

  6. Pingback: their site

  7. Pingback: the creek floor plan

  8. Pingback: mediums/medium

  9. Pingback: Helderzienden online: Live helderziende - Heldervoelende helderziende

  10. Pingback: boost lol

  11. Pingback: Websiteoptimalisatie/websiteoptimaliseren

  12. Pingback: click here

  13. Pingback: paragnost

  14. Pingback: core products

  15. Pingback: Think Build Websites

  16. Pingback: hefalimp cardijon

  17. Pingback: pa hire

  18. Pingback: water damage restoration houston

  19. Pingback: Gerard Walsh cork

  20. Pingback: tadalafil 20 milligrams 20

  21. Pingback: health benefits of apple cider vinegar

  22. Pingback: cialis livraison 24h

  23. Pingback: what does premature ejaculation look like

  24. Pingback: online slots

  25. Pingback: Kali Chaudhuri

  26. Pingback: more,

  27. Pingback: divorce lawyer

  28. Pingback: You Can Try This Out

  29. Pingback: how to stop from premature ejaculation

  30. Pingback: acheter du cialis en france

  31. Pingback: waarzegster

  32. Pingback: no credit check payday loans

  33. Pingback: cialis monografia

  34. Pingback: how to reduce premature ejaculation

  35. Pingback: automotive

  36. Pingback: Home Improvement

  37. Pingback: muslim goat sex

  38. Pingback: visit our website

  39. Pingback: great

  40. Pingback: reference

  41. Pingback: tannreiser.info

  42. Pingback: noumax.com

  43. Pingback: champlinwireless.info

  44. Pingback: free instagram followers fab cc1

  45. Pingback: download bokep 3gp

  46. Pingback: kenribotsky.info

  47. Pingback: districtvii.info

  48. Pingback: rishwan.info

  49. Pingback: buy real twitter followers

  50. Pingback: Cialis bruciore di stomaco

  51. Pingback: Corina R. Jones

  52. Pingback: bitcoin casino

  53. Pingback: gasde.info

  54. Pingback: mmpr licensed producers mmpr licensed producers

  55. Pingback: pieterwellens.info

  56. Pingback: buy youtube likes

  57. Pingback: arganolie discount

  58. Pingback: lawyer directory

  59. Pingback: leadshare.info

  60. Pingback: angelagiese.info

  61. Pingback: wgtop.info

  62. Pingback: nutribullet pro

  63. Pingback: e-cig

  64. Pingback: Home

  65. Pingback: health

  66. Pingback: buy vicodin

  67. Pingback: try searching here

  68. Pingback: novelty techpoint

  69. Pingback: tomturbo.info

  70. Pingback: radiostudiox.info

  71. Pingback: Alexander Begum personal injury

  72. Pingback: why not

  73. Pingback: New Songs 2014

  74. Pingback: Pension

  75. Pingback: Ultralase Reviews

  76. Pingback: derekoleary.info

  77. Pingback: Orlando vacation rentals

  78. Pingback: Paignton Driving School

  79. Pingback: testinate 250

  80. Pingback: Penis enlargement

  81. Pingback: Shaahin Cheyene

  82. Pingback: ροζ τηλέφωνα

  83. Pingback: thai massage

  84. Pingback: Penis enlargement

  85. Pingback: bestlipolosangeles.info

  86. Pingback: small business

  87. Pingback: cialis modo d'uso

  88. Pingback: www.law.fsu.edu

  89. Pingback: cupboards

  90. Pingback: cupboards

  91. Pingback: document management

  92. Pingback: kitchens

  93. Pingback: kitchens

  94. Pingback: เช่าชุดราตรี ปิ่นเกล้า

  95. Pingback: simulateur-scellier.info

  96. Pingback: rundum zürich

  97. Pingback: how do you cure premature ejaculation

  98. Pingback: hills home market

  99. Pingback: Richard McArthur Realtor

  100. Pingback: Flight Tickets

  101. Pingback: Richard McArthur Reid Realty

  102. Pingback: Richard McArthur Real Estate

  103. Pingback: ford raptor rear bumper

  104. Pingback: mortgage broker

  105. Pingback: cheap ebikes

  106. Pingback: cheap ebikes

  107. Pingback: commander cialis en ligne

  108. Pingback: buy cheap likes

  109. Pingback: cheap ebikes

  110. Pingback: cialis prezzi in farmacia

  111. Pingback: cult education

  112. Pingback: Penis enlargement

  113. Pingback: cupones

  114. Pingback: read

  115. Pingback: how to treat delayed ejaculation

  116. Pingback: New Songs List

  117. Pingback: electric bike

  118. Pingback: garage doors san francisco

  119. Pingback: stresser

  120. Pingback: Tips Madden 15 strategy

  121. Pingback: how to find success in online dating

  122. Pingback: بفركس شركة

  123. Pingback: bforex احتيال

  124. Pingback: Empower Network Income proof

  125. Pingback: Mortgage company

  126. Pingback: metatron cube

  127. Pingback: porn online

  128. Pingback: Home Improvement

  129. Pingback: Faucet Repair

  130. Pingback: Skip Trowel Texture

  131. Pingback: Popcorn Ceiling Removal

  132. Pingback: visit the next document

  133. Pingback: Illinois Process Servers

  134. Pingback: Classes

  135. Pingback: car key replacement

  136. Pingback: cool android apps for android

  137. Pingback: daniel wellington

  138. Pingback: Illinois Flat Fee MLS

  139. Pingback: author

  140. Pingback: Get The Facts About Remarkamobile

  141. Pingback: Mortgage brokers

  142. Pingback: werbung

  143. Pingback: renta de autos en cancun

  144. Pingback: Best online auction sites

  145. Pingback: this caregiver

  146. Pingback: los angeles traffic ticket lawyer 2.42K

  147. Pingback: Alexandria dryer vent cleaning

  148. Pingback: Canon Camera

  149. Pingback: forex robot

  150. Pingback: wood gadgets

  151. Pingback: Dan Garcia

  152. Pingback: Mclean dryer vent cleaning

  153. Pingback: renta de autos en cancun

  154. Pingback: kalsium

  155. Pingback: irvine auto repair

  156. Pingback: android games

  157. Pingback: Honey Bee Removal Kingwood Texas

Comments are closed.