The Tragic Beauty of Google+

Harry McCracken has a pretty good articulation of the conventional wisdom about Google+:

Google+ is exuberant. It’s fun to use. And yet I’m pretty positive I won’t spend remotely as much time in it as I will in Facebook. You might have already guessed why: My friends, family and acquaintances are all on Facebook, where they add up to a bustling community I enjoy being part of. More than any particular feature that Mark Zuckerberg and company have cooked up, it’s the people in my life that make Facebook, well, Facebook…

I don’t feel guilty about favoring the social network that feels more like an extension of my world. That’s Facebook. And since Facebook exists, I don’t have much of an incentive to pour more energy into Google+. The two services aren’t identical in particulars and emphasis — today’s Facebook seems to be built on the philosophy that everyone should share everything at all times, sometimes in an automated fashion, and Google+ isn’t like that at all — but ultimately, they scratch the same itch.

I don’t know much about itches, but I believe the conventional wisdom is wrong: from Google’s perspective, Google+ is not a social network meant to compete with Facebook. Rather, it’s an identity system that follows you everywhere.1

Think about it: what is more valuable? Inane chatter, memes, and baby photos, or every single activity you do online (and increasingly offline)? Google+ is about unifying all of Google’s services under a single log-in which can be tracked across the Internet on every site that serves Google ads, uses Google sign-in, or utilizes Google analytics.2

Every feature of Google+ – or of YouTube, or Maps, or GMail, or any other service – is a flytrap meant to ensure you are logged in and being logged by Google at all times.3

Google’s mission is ostensibly “To organize the world’s information and make it universally accessible and useful.”

That was once true, but a better formulation today is: “To organize user information and make it universally trackable and marketable.”

Make no mistake, Google+ has been a massive success. Credit to Google for their willingness to be misunderstood and portrayed as a loser even as they mine information Mark Zuckerberg can’t even dream of.4

  1. Not that Google doesn’t love the social stuff, but that’s icing on the cake
  2. I was challenged on this point, and originally hedged, but I believe it’s true. It’s not clear technically how it would be done, but the terms of use for Google Analytics were amended to allow this. See this thread on Hacker News for both points of view. I’d love to be proven wrong and will change this if I am.
  3. And they’re successful! I’m signed in right now, and you probably are too.
  4. This is a tad hyperbolic; those ubiquitous “Like” buttons accomplish the same thing for Facebook

45 thoughts on “The Tragic Beauty of Google+

  1. Pingback: The Week in Daily Updates (Week 2) | stratechery by Ben Thompson

  2. Pingback: hemroid relief

  3. Pingback: city gate singapore

  4. Pingback: locked out of car locksmith Channelview TX

  5. Pingback: Privacy is Dead | stratechery by Ben Thompson

  6. Pingback: Bengali Entrepreneur

  7. Pingback: airduct cleaning in cornelius nc

  8. Pingback: Ted's Products

  9. Pingback: the creek floor plan

  10. Pingback: mediums/medium

  11. Pingback: royal revolt 2 hack

  12. Pingback: league of legends elo boost

  13. Pingback: Helderzienden online: Live helderziende - Heldervoelende helderziende

  14. Pingback: boost lol

  15. Pingback: paragnost

  16. Pingback: nfs

  17. Pingback:

  18. Pingback: paragnost/klikhier/

  19. Pingback: Websiteoptimalisatie

  20. Pingback: how to build a wordpress website

  21. Pingback: Warren

  22. Pingback: lol boost

  23. Pingback: Dentist Peoria Az

  24. Pingback: halong bay cruise

  25. Pingback: How often should my carpet be cleaned?

  26. Pingback: department store online

  27. Pingback: Jonathan L. Kendall

  28. Pingback: Find Doctors Express

  29. Pingback: emergency power generator

  30. Pingback: click here

  31. Pingback: visit site

  32. Pingback: university of south australia diploma

  33. Pingback: St George UT

  34. Pingback:

  35. Pingback: download movies

  36. Pingback:

  37. Pingback: accident in car

  38. Pingback: seo essex

  39. Pingback:

  40. Pingback: rapid rivet corp.

  41. Pingback: #houndeddogcrates

  42. Pingback: Marina one pricing

  43. Pingback: visit site

  44. Pingback: trivandrum apartments

  45. Pingback: Highline residences

Comments are closed.