Two Bears

In fact, Evans1 wrote two bear arguments.

Bear Argument #1

Bear Argument #1 is the imminent collapse of the iPhone in the face of significantly lower-cost alternatives:

As the industry moves on from converting featurephone buyers to fighting for replacement purchases, what happens to value? Growth for any given manufacturer necessarily becomes a matter of taking sales away from other smartphone manufacturers, not featurephone manufacturers (i.e. Nokia). Moreover, Moore’s Law is at work, driving down prices; you can now get a 4.5″ dual core Android phone from Huawei for just $200, and one from a generic Chinese manufacturer for $120-$150.

This is clearly a challenge for any handset OEM, but especially for one at the high end. There are fewer and fewer new high-end buyers coming into the market and the ones you sold to in the past may increasingly be tempted by ever improving cheaper phones. So a high-end phone maker risks losing sales if it stays at the high-end, or losing margin if it makes cheaper phones, or both.

In case it isn’t obvious, this is the essence of the bear story for Apple.

Bear Argument #2

Bear Argument #2 is the end of growth for the iPhone:

Smartphones sales may be approaching saturation (especially in the USA), but iPhone sales at the end of 2012 were just 10% of global phone sales – and 17% of global contract sales, which is more relevant since it reflects the subsidised market (of course, the possible decline of subsidies is another, rather separate bear story for any handset sold for over $200).

Is 17% the total potential market for a premium phone? Will market share only move from $600 phones to $300 phones, and never the other way? That might be the case if phones were fungible commodities, but they clearly aren’t – otherwise $600 Android phones wouldn’t sell at all. It is entirely possible that the premium phone market is here to stay, and that it could expand significantly.

In this case, the iPhone has saturated the high end, and while current iPhone users replace their iPhones, their overall numbers don’t increase significantly.

To my mind, this is the far more reasonable position. iPhone penetration seems to closely track carrier average revenue per user:

iOS Browser Share Roughly Tracks Carrier ARPU — Click for original article

iOS Browser Share Roughly Tracks Carrier ARPU — Click for original article

The largest remaining carrier without the iPhone – China Mobile – is solidly on the right side of that graph, along with most of the other high-growth countries. Apple may need to produce a lower-cost iPhone to compete, which will of course put significant pressure on their margins. It’s fair to ask if iPhone profit growth has peaked.

Only Bear Argument #2 Makes Sense

Bear Arguments #1 rests on the assumption that the iPhone is competing on hardware, and is therefore susceptible to lower-cost alternatives. However, the iPhone is not simply a device. Rather, it’s a ticket into an ecosystem (characterized here as the Mobile Hierarchy of Needs):

The Mobile Hierarchy of Needs - click image for original article

The Mobile Hierarchy of Needs – click image for original article

This ecosystem is sticky, and users want to stay. According to the Yankee Group:

Of those surveyed, 91 percent of iPhone owners intend to buy another iPhone, while 6 percent plan to switch to an Android device with their next purchase. In other words, more than nine out of 10 iPhone owners are loyal to the platform. Once you buy an iPhone, chances are high you’re going to buy another.

That’s not quite as true for Android. Yankee found that 76 percent of Android owners intend to buy another Android phone. A big number, sure. But it means that 24 percent of Android phone users plan to switch to another platform. Guess where the majority of those professed switchers are going — 18 percent to iPhones.

Current iPhone customers aren’t going anywhere, even if Android continues to fall in price.

Almost all industries have two tenable positions: the differentiated high-end, and the low-cost low-end:

Sustainable Competitive Advantages

Sustainable Competitive Advantages

The iPhone faces little threat in the differentiated high-end of the market. Suggesting this market is limited in size is fair; counting the days until customers flee for cheap phones is silly.2

The Bear Argument for Samsung

That’s not to say that Bear Argument #1 is invalid; in fact, it’s the Bear Argument for Samsung.

There is precious little that differentiates high-end Android from low-end Android. The second, third, and fourth layers3 of the mobile hierarchy are identical; the difference is the hardware, and not only are low-end devices increasingly “good enough,” they’re also impossibly cheap.

I’ve written previously about MediaTek, the Taiwanese chipmaker that dominates this space, but Qualcomm wants a piece as well. From (always questionable) Digitimes:

Qualcomm and Spreadtrum Communications have both cut prices for their quad-core products to better compete against MediaTek, which controls half of the smartphone-chip market in China, according to industry sources.

Qualcomm recently quoted its quad-core solutions at less than US$10, slightly cheaper than MediaTek’s offerings, the sources indicated. Meanwhile, Spreadtrum has lowered its quad-core processor prices to similar levels. Both firms are trying to gain market share through aggressive pricing, the sources said.

Chinese OEM’s you’ve never heard of are making millions of smartphones using these chips. The largest of these is China Wireless. From Bloomberg:

China Wireless Technologies Ltd., the nation’s third-largest smartphone vendor, said it will eventually overtake market leaders Samsung Electronics Co. and Lenovo Group Ltd., helped by demand for low-cost phones.

A 50 percent surge in smartphone shipments will allow China Wireless to pass Lenovo for the No. 2 spot this year, while catching Samsung will take longer, Chief Financial Officer Jiang Chao said in a Bloomberg Television interview yesterday…

Total smartphone shipments in China will rise 44 percent to 300 million units this year, driven by handsets costing about 700 yuan ($113), researcher IDC forecast in December. Demand is surging as China Mobile Ltd., the world’s largest carrier by subscribers, aggressively encourages users of second-generation networks to upgrade to third-generation service with low- and middle-end smartphones. China Wireless, formed in 1993, has sold phones through China Mobile for a decade.

$10 chips, $113 dollar phones. No differentiation in software, apps, or services. Samsung actually sells most of their devices on the low end, but this low?

While the iPhone may have plateaued, it’s Samsung that should be worried about a cliff.

  1. Benedict Evans is one of the single most insightful people on Twitter. Must-follow
  2. To be clear, from conversation, I don’t think Evans subscribes to this theory, but others do
  3. In fact, the fourth layer, especially in China, is very differentiated, but that is (mostly) to the benefit of users

218 thoughts on “Two Bears

  1. Pingback: divorce lawyers middlesex county nj

  2. Pingback: p4 english

  3. Pingback: viagra

  4. Pingback: houston tx

  5. Pingback: look what i found

  6. Pingback: air duct cleaning in charlotte

  7. Pingback: the creek floor plan

  8. Pingback: Helderzienden online: Live helderziende - Heldervoelende helderziende

  9. Pingback: mediums/medium

  10. Pingback: waarzegsters

  11. Pingback: Smartphone Truths and Samsung's Inevitable Decline | stratechery by Ben Thompson

  12. Pingback: Websiteoptimalisatie/klikhier/websiteoptimalisatie

  13. Pingback: Bitcoin Hosting

  14. Pingback: paragnost/klikhier/

  15. Pingback: paragnost en paragnosten direct beschikbaar!

  16. Pingback: Real Ways to Make Money on the Internet

  17. Pingback: Watch Video

  18. Pingback: Think Build Websites

  19. Pingback: Liberty

  20. Pingback: visit site

  21. Pingback: reviews on garcinia cambogia

  22. Pingback: hefalimp cardijon

  23. Pingback: Kali Chaudhuri

  24. Pingback:

  25. Pingback: generiques cialis

  26. Pingback: achat cialis generique

  27. Pingback: best online slots

  28. Pingback: Kali P Chaudhuri

  29. Pingback: cialis 10mg prix en pharmacie

  30. Pingback: dog bed

  31. Pingback: hvac technicians

  32. Pingback: how to make it last longer in bed

  33. Pingback:

  34. Pingback: commander cialis soft

  35. Pingback: Halong Bay Cruises

  36. Pingback: payday loans for bad credit

  37. Pingback: Paediatric Dentist

  38. Pingback: cialis e prostata

  39. Pingback: penis enlargement pills

  40. Pingback: cialis 5 mg daily

  41. Pingback: mmpr licensed producers mmpr licensed producers

  42. Pingback: arganolie discount

  43. Pingback: sonos sale

  44. Pingback: viagra

  45. Pingback: xlovecam generator

  46. Pingback: l arginine for premature ejaculation

  47. Pingback: try here

  48. Pingback: Ultralase

  49. Pingback: site

  50. Pingback: Top 100 Songs

  51. Pingback: Detroit

  52. Pingback: massage dublin

  53. Pingback: Orlando vacation rentals

  54. Pingback: cialis mutuabile

  55. Pingback: healthy snacks

  56. Pingback: Shaahin

  57. Pingback: Bitcoin casino

  58. Pingback: Shaahin Cheyene

  59. Pingback: nature's comfort reviews

  60. Pingback: kitchens

  61. Pingback: rundum zürich

  62. Pingback: hills home market

  63. Pingback: เช่าชุดราตรี ปิ่นเกล้า

  64. Pingback: หมอสมหมาย

  65. Pingback: Charles Floate

  66. Pingback: Richard McArthur Reid Real Estate

  67. Pingback: Flight Tickets

  68. Pingback: Richard McArthur Realtor

  69. Pingback: Richard McArthur Silverton

  70. Pingback: Richard McArthur Realtor

  71. Pingback: Richard McArthur Silverton

  72. Pingback: raptor bumper

  73. Pingback: cialis comparatif prix

  74. Pingback: buy facebook cheap

  75. Pingback: Christian boarding schools

  76. Pingback: cialis 20 mg effetti collaterali

  77. Pingback: Penis enlargement

  78. Pingback: distante rutiere

  79. Pingback: raleigh wedding films

  80. Pingback: this blog

  81. Pingback:

  82. Pingback: outlook

  83. Pingback: ed maldonado

  84. Pingback: New Songs List

  85. Pingback: love systems online dating

  86. Pingback: love online games dating

  87. Pingback: doc love online dating

  88. Pingback: dbz power levels

  89. Pingback: how to control premature ejaculation naturally

  90. Pingback: M88

  91. Pingback: emily bronte everyman

  92. Pingback: 1-800-411-pain

  93. Pingback: dbz games

  94. Pingback: make money online fast

  95. Pingback: Inner Circle

  96. Pingback: metatron cube

  97. Pingback: Ceiling Fan Installation

  98. Pingback: Home Improvement

  99. Pingback: porn cam

  100. Pingback: Skip Trowel Texture

  101. Pingback: Knockdown Texture

  102. Pingback: one-time offer

  103. Pingback: shakeology shake reviews

  104. Pingback: penis vergrößern

  105. Pingback: What About Remarkamobile

  106. Pingback: healthy lifestyle

  107. Pingback: Restore My Vision Today Review

  108. Pingback: Northern Virginia dryer vent cleaning

  109. Pingback: kvar

  110. Pingback: online auction sites uk

  111. Pingback: Manufactured home loans

  112. Pingback: assisted living

  113. Pingback: NOVA Dryer Vent Cleaning

  114. Pingback: forex robot

  115. Pingback: renta de autos en cancun

  116. Pingback: Golden Hints

  117. Pingback: proteiinit urheiluun

  118. Pingback: Honey Bee Removal Kingwood Texas

  119. Pingback: Casino games

  120. Pingback: mazda new

  121. Pingback: renta de autos en cancun

  122. Pingback: cialis pour diabete

  123. Pingback: ejakulation

  124. Pingback: free instagram followers

  125. Pingback: hyundai gurnee

  126. Pingback: Porno Filmes

  127. Pingback: legal highs uk

  128. Pingback: Criminal Lawyer

  129. Pingback: fish oil omega 3

  130. Pingback: used car dealerships

  131. Pingback: Bladder cancer cells triggers.

  132. Pingback: One little mortgage website that could save you hundreds!

  133. Pingback: more info

  134. Pingback: Medicines Online

  135. Pingback: sencey

  136. Pingback: do i need glasses

  137. Pingback: minecraft like games

  138. Pingback: click here

  139. Pingback: Muita esporra

  140. Pingback: medicare eye exam

  141. Pingback: coupon

  142. Pingback: Viagra Now

  143. Pingback: Hudson

  144. Pingback: Illinois Service of Process

  145. Pingback: advertise property for sale

  146. Pingback: Afford a Home with these tips...

  147. Pingback: games app

  148. Pingback: Virus

  149. Pingback: canoe

  150. Pingback: Chicago IL For Sale By Owner

  151. Pingback: Rashida Ruppel

  152. Pingback: Miami FL For Sale By Owner

  153. Pingback: Domitila Dorge

  154. Pingback: desktop computer reviews

  155. Pingback: machines sewing

  156. Pingback: best trading system

  157. Pingback: Legacy Food Storage

  158. Pingback: address book xp location

  159. Pingback: labor day 2014

  160. Pingback: hydrating facial mask

  161. Pingback: gordas rodando

  162. Pingback: navy seals fitness

  163. Pingback: cialis 5 mg once a day

  164. Pingback: art

  165. Pingback: quality top brand name wheels

  166. Pingback: presbicia yahoo

  167. Pingback: Betboo

  168. Pingback: Chimney Sweep

  169. Pingback: Viagra

  170. Pingback: Viagra

  171. Pingback: bets10

  172. Pingback: megaphone

  173. Pingback: vehicle

  174. Pingback: dwi book

  175. Pingback: health and beauty

  176. Pingback: Learn How To Make Cash With Instagram

  177. Pingback: harga jam casio

  178. Pingback: gold nutrition

  179. Pingback: list

  180. Pingback: iphone6

  181. Pingback: Coupons

  182. Pingback: assfuck

  183. Pingback: make money on twitter

  184. Pingback: superbahis kayit

  185. Pingback: Offer Wall

  186. Pingback: Nike Coupon Code

  187. Pingback: Troy

  188. Pingback: Troy college planning

  189. Pingback: german shepherd training

  190. Pingback: bee wild pest control

  191. Pingback: pest control houston review

  192. Pingback: appliance repair in Yonkers NY

  193. Pingback: discount juicy couture

  194. Pingback: Whatsapp Status

  195. Pingback: garcinia cambogia free bottle

  196. Pingback: you could look here

  197. Pingback: Reseller pack 4

  198. Pingback: MovieStarPlanet Cheats Hack

  199. Pingback: Alternative Energy Generators

  200. Pingback: what does premature ejaculation look like

  201. Pingback: easeus data recovery

  202. Pingback: data recovery mac

  203. Pingback: Guitar Licks You’ll Love - “Stand By Me” on Guitar

  204. Pingback: openappmkt

  205. Pingback: file recovery mac

  206. Pingback: ayia napa

  207. Pingback: world business directory

  208. Pingback: Cialis

  209. Pingback: recover deleted files mac

  210. Pingback: Free Download Register Software's

  211. Pingback: seo and local maps package houston

  212. Pingback: House eviction

  213. Pingback: at home care

  214. Pingback: modere products

  215. Pingback: viagra online

  216. Pingback: appliance repair Cave Creek

  217. Pingback: sex online

  218. Pingback: Baltasar sanchez haz

Comments are closed.