stratechery
stratechery

Android Where?

There is no questioning the scope of Google’s ambitions. Consider the fact that yesterday’s two-and-a-half hour keynote was shorter than the 2013 version, and that the two keynotes had almost zero overlap!

While last year Google spent a lot of time both enhancing the Android development environment and Google+, this year was about extending Android to a whole host of new devices, including watches, cars, and TVs. However, just because Android has been an unqualified success on phones – and deservedly so – I’m a bit dubious as to how well Google’s vision will translate to the next generation of devices, in particular Android Wear.

Note: I reviewed all of Google’s announcement in today’s Daily Update (members-only)

Watches Are Not Phones

Beyond the rather obvious fact that one is on your wrist and the other is in your pocket, the primary difference between a watch and your phone is that you buy the former by choice and the latter by necessity. This has a significant effect on not just the size of the addressable market, but also the type of buyer in that market.

Because a phone is a necessity – everyone is going to buy one – there is going to be a very large segment of the market whose purchase decision is driven primarily by price. In turn, this means the minimum acceptable product with the lowest price is going to garner the largest market share. Indeed that is exactly what has happened with phones: while the iPhone is actually increasing its dominance of the high end, Android has covered the entire rest of the market. And, as we learned yesterday, that market is now >1 billion in size (and the purpose of Android One is to capture the huge swathes who cannot or will not pay more than $100).

To put it another way, in the case of a phone, the only decision to make is which phone to buy. When it comes to a watch or other wearable, though, there is another question that has to be answered first: do I even want to buy one at all.

This additional question will make wearables a much more difficult market for Android to crack. Instead of simply making available an item the customer needs to buy at a low price, the wearable maker must first demonstrate a reason to buy into the category in the first place, and only then does price come into play. Moreover, any item that is purchased because you want it is a sort of luxury good, at least relative to something you buy because you need it, which by extension means the percentage of buyers who will prefer a premium option will be much greater. This is the primary reason why Android’s tablet share is much less than its phone market share, and its usage share lower still.

New Devices Need New Interfaces

In many respects Google’s push to take their dominant platform and port it to what’s next is reminiscent of Microsoft’s previous attempts to take their dominant platform – Windows – and port it to phones. Which is why the Pocket PC 2000 (a.k.a. Windows Mobile v1) looked like this:

A screenshot from Pocket PC 2000 (Windows Mobile 1.0)

A screenshot from Pocket PC 2000 (Windows Mobile 1.0)

We laugh now at the idea of shrinking a PC UI to a phone, but I got the same sense from the Android Wear UI:

Notifications on Android Wear

Notifications on Android Wear

It’s hard to see the notification UI clearly, but it basically looks the exact same as a phone notification, just shrunk down. And, just like the phone, you swipe to dismiss. Sure, it’s very cool how the notification then disappears from the phone, but at the end of the day it’s hard to escape the feeling that you’re simply wearing a second phone on your wrist. Is saving the effort of reaching into your pocket really worth the cost, not just in dollars, but also in comfort and fashion? I’m skeptical, and it’s hard to see a device like Android Wear being anything more than a niche product, just like Windows Mobile.

Is Now the Future?

Notifications are nice, but probably the biggest selling point of Android Wear is as a conduit for Android Now. It’s Now that to my mind really speaks to Google’s ambition: having mastered the world’s information, Google is now focusing on the individual. Now seeks to be your digital personal assistant, anticipating your needs and providing you the information you need when you need it (and, of course, building one heck of an advertising profile). And, when it comes to just-in-time information, the presentation of which is initiated by your device, a watch is in fact a rather compelling addition to a smartphone. After all, as long as your phone is in your pocket you may not see the reminder about your upcoming meeting, or that you ought to leave a few minutes early because of bad traffic. By virtue of being in a more accessible place on your body a watch may be superior for this sort of passive interaction.

I question, though, if Now will turn out to be as meaningful to most people as Google thinks it will be. In other words, how many people actually want a personal digital assistant? There is an alternative view of computers in which they are more akin to a tool, something you pick up and use to do a job, and then set down when you are done with it. To be sure, that tool is incredibly powerful and capable of doing a great number of jobs, but it still operates in service of something outside of computers.

Consider your Android phone: it’s a way to connect with friends and family, a way to entertain yourself, a way to capture memories, and a way to learn. It’s meaningful because it lets you do what you want to do better. A digital assistant, on the other hand, is simply a more efficient way of interacting with your computer – or your computer interacting with you – and I question how much that vision that will ultimately resonate with people.


During yesterday’s keynote Benedict Evans posted this tweet:

I think there is more than a grain of truth here when it comes to Google, but I do feel Apple thinks about computing differently. Recall Steve Jobs’ famous characterization of the Mac – a bicycle for the mind. While a bicycle makes a human more efficient, it still depends on that human for locomotion and direction. I think we see that today with Siri. Siri does not try to anticipate your needs or tell you what to do, instead she responds to questions delivered by humans, helping them to find the answers far more efficiently than they could on their own.

The true test, of course, will come when we see Apple’s wearable. All of the criticisms I have levied against Android Wear potentially apply to Apple’s offering, particular the lack of a reason-to-buy. More fundamentally, though, the philosophical question I have raised is at the root of which company you think is more likely to own the future. Google already has the best computer, and their lead is only increasing; Apple, though, has always made the best bicycles.

323 thoughts on “Android Where?

  1. What Google did, I think, is prove that Android Wear devices can be excellent remote controls for Android phones. And, of course, a remote control for your mobile is definitely a luxury. No one really needs it.

    So I certainly don’t see myself buying LG or Samsung’s offerings. LG’s watch may be a great little remote, but I can’t justify $229 for it.

    But I think Google learned from its tablet related woes. They’ve come out with a hero product that people want. The entire I/O audience groaned when it was announced the Moto 360 would take some time to come out. I did too, and I’d spend up to $360 to get one.

    A watch is a fashion accessory, and if Google can promote Wear as an add on to fashion accessories that can raise their usefulness, I suspect they’ll have greater success than they did with tablets. Not a phone on your wrist, but a wristwatch with cool boiled-down phone features that can talk with your phone out of the box.

    And then there’s the fitness/health aspect. Google Fit definitely plays with Android Wear, and I suspect the reason it wasn’t introduced while they were talking about Wear is because the two current offerings don’t do much that is fitness related. I suspect the 360, or a future product, will have to fill that gap.

  2. Pingback: Google I/O: A couple of days with Android Wear | ProcessOne Blog

  3. Pingback: Bookmarks for June 27th from 16:26 to 21:43 : Extenuating Circumstances

  4. Pingback: Incognitosis de fin de semana (XIX) | Incognitosis

  5. Pingback: Additional Thoughts on iWatch and Android Wear | stratechery by Ben Thompson

  6. Pingback: 智能穿戴:Android Wear把控虚拟空间,iWatch控制现实世界 | BITMAIN

  7. Pingback: 智能穿戴:Android Wear把控虚拟空间,iWatch控制现实世界 | 国外资讯 | 极氪世界

  8. Pingback: 智能穿戴:Android Wear把控虚拟空间,iWatch控制现实世界-特:中国

  9. Pingback: 智能穿戴:Android Wear把控虚拟空间,iWatch控制现实世界 | 我爱互联网

  10. Pingback: 智能穿戴:Android Wear把控虚拟空间,iWatch控制现实世界 | 36氪 | What Happen Today?!?

  11. Pingback: 智能穿戴:Android Wear把控虚拟空间,iWatch控制现实世界 - 科技辣

  12. Pingback: 智能穿戴:Android Wear把控虚拟空间,iWatch控制现实世界-极客娲母

  13. Pingback: The Current Crop of Smart Watches are Dead on Arrival | Thoughts on Tech

  14. Pingback: El largo recorrido del reloj inteligente | Incognitosis

  15. Pingback: Android Wear把控虚拟空间,iWatch控制现实世界–淘宝360新闻网 - 淘宝360新闻网

  16. Pingback: hefalimp cardijon

  17. Pingback: tadalafil en france

  18. Pingback: best online slots

  19. Pingback: chicken coop ideas

  20. Pingback: this website,

  21. Pingback: music download

  22. Pingback: background check free

  23. Pingback: dog bed

  24. Pingback: cialis original en ligne

  25. Pingback: great post to read

  26. Pingback: iphone 5 unlock

  27. Pingback: acheter cialis ou viagra

  28. Pingback: URL

  29. Pingback: Android Wear把控虚拟空间,iWatch控制现实世界 | 23Seed

  30. Pingback: cialis pour premiere fois

  31. Pingback: xxx goats

  32. Pingback: buy real followers vimeo

  33. Pingback: cialis prezzi in farmacia

  34. Pingback: mmpr licensed producers mmpr licensed producers

  35. Pingback: arganolie discount

  36. Pingback: lawyer

  37. Pingback: smokeless cigarettes

  38. Pingback: onkyo nr929 review

  39. Pingback: xlovecam free tokens

  40. Pingback: san antonio lawyer alexander begum

  41. Pingback: cialis dove si trova

  42. Pingback: how to naturally last longer in bed for men

  43. Pingback: training to last longer in bed

  44. Pingback: cialis authentique suisse

  45. Pingback: Drywall Finishing

  46. Pingback: Faucet Repair

  47. Pingback: Skip Trowel Texture

  48. Pingback: Popcorn Ceiling Removal

  49. Pingback: shakeology doctor review

  50. Pingback: cool android apps 2013

  51. Pingback: daniel wellington

  52. Pingback: e-books

  53. Pingback: Flat Fee MLS Realtor IL

  54. Pingback: restore my vision today discount

  55. Pingback: werbung

  56. Pingback: sports

  57. Pingback: free business classifieds

  58. Pingback: traffic ticket attorney los angeles 217K 140

  59. Pingback: best forex robot

  60. Pingback: Sir Robert Gordon Menzies Scholar

  61. Pingback: Ron Martinez

  62. Pingback: read more

  63. Pingback: ryppyvoide

  64. Pingback: Honey Bee Removal Kingwood Texas

  65. Pingback: irvine auto repair

  66. Pingback: Racing games

  67. Pingback: frau befriedigen

  68. Pingback: Mayweather vs Maidana 2

  69. Pingback: work at from home

  70. Pingback: physics chemistry biology tutor

  71. Pingback: mazda peoria il

  72. Pingback: Jasa Add Follower

  73. Pingback: Perbanyak Likes Instagram

  74. Pingback: One little mortgage website that could save you hundreds!

  75. Pingback: essentials norwegian omega 3 fish oil

  76. Pingback: Afford a Home with these tips...

  77. Pingback: doctors in tucson arizona

  78. Pingback: eye exam for contacts

  79. Pingback: Madelyn

  80. Pingback: 6 easy ways to mess up a home purchase!

  81. Pingback: aaron kocourek

  82. Pingback: For Sale By Owner Pittsburgh PA

  83. Pingback: cialis e viagra

  84. Pingback: labor day meaning

  85. Pingback: juicy couture outlet

  86. Pingback: Free android games

  87. Pingback: paginas web managua nicaragua

  88. Pingback: skin facial

  89. Pingback: destiny horoscope

  90. Pingback: Betboo

  91. Pingback: gordas antes y despues de adelgazar

  92. Pingback: exercise equipment for sale

  93. Pingback: presbicia funcional

  94. Pingback: oz racing number one brand wheels

  95. Pingback: home loans

  96. Pingback: navy seal training camp

  97. Pingback: ministerial

  98. Pingback: Coupons

  99. Pingback: Rechargeable pa speakers

  100. Pingback: impaired driving book

  101. Pingback: graphic billboards

  102. Pingback: Learn How To Make Cash With Instagram

  103. Pingback: harga jam tangan casio

  104. Pingback: iphone6

  105. Pingback: bets10

  106. Pingback: Make money from twitter

  107. Pingback: Earn Money

  108. Pingback: potty training a puppy

  109. Pingback: Buy Facebook Likes

  110. Pingback: pest control houston review

  111. Pingback: bee wild pest control

  112. Pingback: cialis generic

  113. Pingback: visit this brand new webpage

  114. Pingback: Celebrity News

  115. Pingback: Natural Stone

  116. Pingback: replacement led projector lamp

  117. Pingback: Cialis

  118. Pingback: uae business directory

  119. Pingback: scuba diving in protaras cyprus

  120. Pingback: Guitar Licks You’ll Love - “Stand By Me” on Guitar

  121. Pingback: openappmkt

  122. Pingback: Free Download Register Software's

  123. Pingback: modere products

  124. Pingback: best online slot machines

  125. Pingback: notepad bluebox

  126. Pingback: buy tramadol

  127. Pingback: buy adderall online

  128. Pingback: hydrocodone without prescription

  129. Pingback: buy hydrocodone

  130. Pingback: buy valium

  131. Pingback: click here

  132. Pingback: free online slot games no download

  133. Pingback: sabotaging relationships

  134. Pingback: golf

  135. Pingback: Free Stuff Every Month

  136. Pingback: slot machine games online

  137. Pingback: DUI Attorneys Denver

  138. Pingback: emotional intelligence training

  139. Pingback: sigue leyendo

  140. Pingback: m?s info

  141. Pingback: Venture Capital or VC Funding Consultants

  142. Pingback: sinema izle

  143. Pingback: m88

  144. Pingback: cash for gold

  145. Pingback: MovieStarPlanet Cheats

  146. Pingback: icmeler transfers

  147. Pingback: voyage lune de miel

  148. Pingback: her explanation

  149. Pingback: have a peek here

  150. Pingback: Tempe Glass Repair

  151. Pingback: CPCS Answers

  152. Pingback: wordpress perth

  153. Pingback: plum lipstick

  154. Pingback: this web page

  155. Pingback: web design company in perth

  156. Pingback: MOLPoints generator

  157. Pingback: mayweather vs maidana 2 live

  158. Pingback: free online puzzle game

  159. Pingback: Exterminator Service Houston Texas

  160. Pingback: Devvon Terrell Jason Derulo Marry Me Cover Is Breath Taking

  161. Pingback: xlovecam telecharger generateur de code

  162. Pingback: Desmond Kuek

  163. Pingback: FanDuel Promo Code

  164. Pingback: Pest Control Richmond Texas

  165. Pingback: epub gratis

  166. Pingback: teen chat app

  167. Pingback: badmintonschläger test

  168. Pingback: emotional intelligence training

  169. Pingback: free online slots with bonus

  170. Pingback: Download Free Japanese Idols Beautiful Sexy Latest

  171. Pingback: gap visa credit card

  172. Pingback: designer saree gown

  173. Pingback: vape

  174. Pingback: confetti cones

  175. Pingback: Sydney Wedding Photography

  176. Pingback: property in cardiff

  177. Pingback: foder conas peludas

  178. Pingback: best online slots games

  179. Pingback: buy wine online uk

  180. Pingback: Citibank Locations

  181. Pingback: sewa elf surabaya termurah

  182. Pingback: recommended gold ira companies

  183. Pingback: Colusa Criminal Defense Attorney

  184. Pingback: macchina fotografica reflex inglese per principianti

  185. Pingback: Lettings agent surbiton

  186. Pingback: Sinisterly - Advanced Hacking Methods

  187. Pingback: cialis

  188. Pingback: achat cialis 20 mg

  189. Pingback: Carpet cleaners glasgow

  190. Pingback: kitchen fitters manchester

  191. Pingback: celebrity leaked photos

  192. Pingback: banana blue

  193. Pingback: tutorials

  194. Pingback: Luxurious wallet

  195. Pingback: electric bronze- bronzer

  196. Pingback: websites perth

  197. Pingback: meditation music albums

  198. Pingback: Crazy

  199. Pingback: Cialis

  200. Pingback: web design in perth

  201. Pingback: awakening energy

  202. Pingback: iphone 5c hard phone cases

  203. Pingback: family lawyer

  204. Pingback: investing

  205. Pingback: digital marketing perth

  206. Pingback: chewing gum containing xylitol

  207. Pingback: zobacz tutaj

  208. Pingback: search engine optimization techniques

  209. Pingback: loyal 9 reviews

  210. Pingback: App Marketing

  211. Pingback: Related Site

  212. Pingback: Mobile spa

  213. Pingback: Chung cu ct2c Hoàng Qu?c Vit

  214. Pingback: hecigarette review

  215. Pingback: food

  216. Pingback: healthy weight

  217. Pingback: chichiriviche de la costa

  218. Pingback: albanian chat

  219. Pingback: cerebral palsy disability causes

  220. Pingback: CFDs

  221. Pingback: Moving Help

  222. Pingback: Cheryl

  223. Pingback: grosir tas fashion import

  224. Pingback: saint seiya

  225. Pingback: agen bola tangkas

  226. Pingback: Eldon

  227. Pingback: lose weight fast

  228. Pingback: Hiking Sticks

  229. Pingback: buy soundcloud plays uk

  230. Pingback: Oregon Social Security Disability

  231. Pingback: how to make money online

  232. Pingback: Wellness Dog Food Coupon

  233. Pingback: Caller ID Revenue

  234. Pingback: Hack Facebook Account

  235. Pingback: legal separation

  236. Pingback: download bluestacks app player

  237. Pingback: free stuff

  238. Pingback: ofertas peru

  239. Pingback: hearthstone arena guide

  240. Pingback: gamedev

  241. Pingback: learn more

  242. Pingback: Hack Facebook Account

  243. Pingback: elevator cable safety factor

  244. Pingback: systemy przeciwoblodzeniowe

  245. Pingback: naturalne farby do wlosów sklep

  246. Pingback: szkola plywania slask

  247. Pingback: suplementy sklep

  248. Pingback: aromatherapy

  249. Pingback: code gallery

  250. Pingback: certyfikat kwalifikowany zus

  251. Pingback: kobieta po 40

  252. Pingback: activation keys

  253. Pingback: boostmylikes

  254. Pingback: iva

  255. Pingback: quick extender

  256. Pingback: qui?n es Ivan Bedia Garcia

  257. Pingback: presentation videos

  258. Pingback: commonwealth towers review

  259. Pingback: pages jaunes

  260. Pingback: Street Jumpers

  261. Pingback: Gulf Shores condo Rentals

  262. Pingback: here for free

  263. Pingback: arkitekter kobenhavn

  264. Pingback: definitep

  265. Pingback: cleaning company

  266. Pingback: buy instagram followers

  267. Pingback: How to find a good personal injury attorney to help you with your accident or injury claim.

  268. Pingback: free emailing software

  269. Pingback: garden shed plans

  270. Pingback: need a logo

  271. Pingback: e-cigarette-shop

  272. Pingback: stopthestresstoday.com/contact

  273. Pingback: razor bump cream for black men

  274. Pingback: Livejasmin Hack update

  275. Pingback: Patriot Rooter

  276. Pingback: whmcs free

  277. Pingback: costa del mar sunglasses

  278. Pingback: cosmetica organica online

  279. Pingback: Roaches for sale

  280. Pingback: tangkas online

  281. Pingback: riflessi max 1123

  282. Pingback: Office Decoration

  283. Pingback: buy teacup schnauzer online

  284. Pingback: filtros de agua

  285. Pingback: 100 percent aloe vera gel

  286. Pingback: best moving companies in Tampa

  287. Pingback: polecam

  288. Pingback: binary option trading

  289. Pingback: Cleaning Sydney

  290. Pingback: miley cyrus concert

  291. Pingback: Minigolf construction

  292. Pingback: Jogos de carros

  293. Pingback: Real Estate Instructor

  294. Pingback: Zebra Printer Repair

  295. Pingback: atm hire

  296. Pingback: jaipur builders and developers

  297. Pingback: atms for event

  298. Pingback: business for sale

  299. Pingback: location bureau pas cher centre ville Montr?al

  300. Pingback: atm hire

  301. Pingback: Erzurum Evden eve Nakliyat

  302. Pingback: Aprender ingles en linea

  303. Pingback: WP Profit Builder

  304. Pingback: anuncios

  305. Pingback: yisites.com

  306. Pingback: gender prediction quiz

  307. Pingback: spriderman surprise eggs

  308. Pingback: Patriot Rooter

  309. Pingback: international courier services in himayathnagar

  310. Pingback: resource

  311. Pingback: sub zero refrigerator repair venice ca

  312. Pingback: one bed flat to let in london

  313. Pingback: M88BET

  314. Pingback: Fun88.Com

  315. Pingback: przyciemnianie szyb slask

  316. Pingback: nagrobki warszawa

  317. Pingback: CDs & Vinyl

  318. Pingback: phone verified

  319. Pingback: indian astrology

  320. Pingback: beaches

  321. Pingback: fut 15 coins

  322. Pingback: pretos a foder brancas

  323. Pingback: printable oil change coupons

Join the Conversation