FiveThirtyEight and the End of Average

Just a few minutes ago, Nate Silver’s new FiveThirtyEight site launched. While it’s not known how much ESPN is paying Silver, it’s certainly a substantial amount, especially when you consider 20% of visitors to the New York Times stopped by Silver’s blog.

Silver’s FiveThirtyEight is one of a growing number of personality-driven sites and blogs, including Ezra Klein and Vox, Andrew Sullivan and his eponymous blog, and Silver’s colleague at ESPN, Bill Simmons of Grantland. All three are successful because of the Internet, their readers (including myself) love them, what’s not to like?

The ongoing death of the newspaper is, particularly among newspaper folks, attributed mostly to the loss of advertising dollars. For example, writing in response to Marc Andreesen’s bullish tweets about the future of news, Ryan Chittum wrote at the Columbia Journalism Review:

The existential problem for the news is that the Internet has unbundled advertising from content creation. The new digital monopolies all have hundreds of millions of people creating free content for them. That’s where the big profits are. Oh, sure, there are major differences between the old newspaper monopoly distribution model and the digital one. But the similarities are greater.

The equivalent of Google, Facebook, and Twitter in the pre-Internet days would be a newspaper that shut down its newsroom, kept the ad department (though replacing much of it with robots), and printed stuff other people wrote. Today, Facebook’s got your weddings, baby announcements, and soccer pictures. Twitter’s got your breaking news. And Google’s got your stock listings, sports scores, news, recipes, etc. Oh yeah, and Craigslist has your classifieds.

The problem with Chittum’s analysis – and why I think he missed Andreesen’s point – is, ironically, his choice of words. “News” does not mean “newspapers,” and while the latter is surely dead, the former is, for readers anyway, entering a golden age.

My father has always subscribed to the paper; The Wisconsin State Journal, specifically, which makes sense, given that I grew up in Madison. As far as newspapers go, the Wisconsin State Journal that I grew up with was probably about average, right in the middle of the bell curve:

Pre-Internet, some papers were great, some were terrible, most were average.

Pre-Internet, some papers were great, some were terrible, most were average.

Long a news hound, I read that paper cover-to-cover throughout high school, and, when I headed off to college, marked the occasion with a subscription to the New York Times. I was moving up in the world.

Today, though, I don’t subscribe to the Times, and I only read an article in the Wisconsin State Journal when I’m visiting my parents and forget to bring my phone into the bathroom. Instead I get most of my news via Twitter, and it’s amazing. Take, for example, this piece I read yesterday about “anonymous” apps like Secret and Twitter: it was posted on Medium, a site built on the idea that nothing matters beyond the content of an individual post, and it was probably the best thing you’ll read on the subject. Over the last 24 hours I’ve also enjoyed this tech piece at Daring Fireball, this basketball piece by Zach Lowe at Grantland, this literary piece from the Guardian, and this culture piece in the New York Times.

The net result is that my news consumption looks a lot more like a power curve than a bell curve:

Today I can afford to read only the best, regardless of where it is published

Today I can afford to read only the best, regardless of where it is published

Most of what I read is the best there is to read on any given subject. The trash is few and far between, and the average equally rare.

This, of course, is made possible by the Internet. No longer are my reading choices constrained by time and especially place. Why should I pick up the Wisconsin State Journal – or the Taipei Times – when I can read Nate Silver, Ezra Klein, Bill Simmons, and the myriad other links served up by Twitter? I, and everyone else interested in news, politics, or sports, can read the best with less effort – and cost – than it ever took to read the merely average just a few short years ago.

Nate Silver’s manifesto for his new site is 3500 words long, meaning it would take the average adult just under 12 minutes to read. That 12 minutes is then gone forever, a bit of attention taken from whatever other activity said reader would have otherwise consumed, and instead gave to Nate Silver. That is why Nate Silver is so valuable.

The implication of my news consumption being dominated by the tall skinny part of the power curve is that those who can regularly appear there – the best of the best – are going to win the zero sum game for my attention. And, for that, they will be justly rewarded.

What then, though, of the tens of thousands of journalists who formerly filled the middle of the bell curve? More broadly – and this is the central challenge to society presented by the Internet – what then of the millions of others in all the other industries touched by the Internet who are perfectly average and thus, in an age where the best is only a click away, are simply not needed?

This is the angst that fills those in the news business, and society broadly. The reality of the Internet is that there is no more bell curve; power laws dominate, and the challenge of our time is figuring out what to do with a population distribution that is fundamentally misaligned with Internet economics.

160 thoughts on “FiveThirtyEight and the End of Average

  1. Pingback: Why the Web Still Matters for Writing | Creation theme wordpress

  2. Pingback: The Net Neutrality Wake-up Call | stratechery by Ben Thompson

  3. Pingback: app to get more followers on instagram

  4. Pingback: zelda 3ds

  5. Pingback: click here

  6. Pingback: hefalimp cardijon

  7. Pingback: carpet cleaning houston

  8. Pingback: cialis viagra levitra comparaison

  9. Pingback: cialis vidal

  10. Pingback: prix du cialis 5

  11. Pingback: How Technology is Changing the World (P&G Edition) | stratechery by Ben Thompson

  12. Pingback: external link,

  13. Pingback: commander cialis quebec

  14. Pingback: music download

  15. Pingback: cialis prezzi in farmacia

  16. Pingback: automotive

  17. Pingback: generique cialis effet secondaire

  18. Pingback: muslim goat sex

  19. Pingback: Home Improvement

  20. Pingback: read here

  21. Pingback: site

  22. Pingback: source here

  23. Pingback:

  24. Pingback:

  25. Pingback:

  26. Pingback: what causes premature ejaculation in men

  27. Pingback:

  28. Pingback:

  29. Pingback: cheap pinterest repins

  30. Pingback: penis enlargement pills

  31. Pingback: cialis mg 5

  32. Pingback:

  33. Pingback: mmpr licensed producers mmpr licensed producers

  34. Pingback:

  35. Pingback:

  36. Pingback: buy youtube likes

  37. Pingback:

  38. Pingback: arganolie discount

  39. Pingback:

  40. Pingback:

  41. Pingback: Atomizers

  42. Pingback:

  43. Pingback: xlovecam credit adder

  44. Pingback: generique cialis 20mg prix

  45. Pingback: Travel

  46. Pingback: Fashion

  47. Pingback: bedroom suites

  48. Pingback: Alexander Begum of The Begum Law Group

  49. Pingback: Robert Shumake

  50. Pingback: More Bonuses

  51. Pingback: Optimax

  52. Pingback: Ultralase

  53. Pingback: Orlando vacation rentals near disney

  54. Pingback: Driving School Torquay

  55. Pingback: cialis professional

  56. Pingback: thai massage dublin

  57. Pingback: thai massage

  58. Pingback: Shaahin

  59. Pingback: nature's comfort reviews

  60. Pingback: Sydney escorts

  61. Pingback:

  62. Pingback: Penis enlargement

  63. Pingback: ροζ γραμμές

  64. Pingback: attorney

  65. Pingback:

  66. Pingback: hills home market

  67. Pingback: kitchen cupboards

  68. Pingback: frases bonitas

  69. Pingback: หมอสมหมาย

  70. Pingback: Charles Floate

  71. Pingback: Flight Tickets

  72. Pingback: Richard McArthur Real Estate

  73. Pingback: cialise notice

  74. Pingback: in here

  75. Pingback: Richard McArthur Reid Realty

  76. Pingback: best wireless speakers

  77. Pingback: Richard McArthur Reid Real Estate

  78. Pingback: Arganollie

  79. Pingback: ford raptor parts

  80. Pingback: raleigh nc wedding videographer

  81. Pingback: amazing porn site

  82. Pingback: buy cheap likes

  83. Pingback: how to last longer in bed sexually

  84. Pingback: Penis enlargement

  85. Pingback: finance trade

  86. Pingback: medicine

  87. Pingback: garden

  88. Pingback: money

  89. Pingback: Viagra

  90. Pingback: legal information

  91. Pingback: real estate

  92. Pingback: bay area garage door

  93. Pingback: visitar

  94. Pingback: Penis enlargement

  95. Pingback: edward maldonado

  96. Pingback: the social media

  97. Pingback: Viagra

  98. Pingback: site

  99. Pingback: salsa en malaga

  100. Pingback: doc love online dating

  101. Pingback: Education

  102. Pingback: Technology

  103. Pingback: dbz online games

  104. Pingback: payday loans

  105. Pingback: Mortgage company

  106. Pingback: online sports betting

  107. Pingback: blog

  108. Pingback: Carey Martell

  109. Pingback: بفركس نصب

  110. Pingback: Join Empower Network

  111. Pingback: website

  112. Pingback: viagra xxx

  113. Pingback: Ceiling Fan Installation

  114. Pingback: Drywall Finishing

  115. Pingback: Skip Trowel Texture

  116. Pingback: click the following document

  117. Pingback: Knockdown Texture

  118. Pingback: Popcorn Ceiling Removal

  119. Pingback: Donate

  120. Pingback: kvar

  121. Pingback: Anyone Can Have Beautiful Hair With These Hair Care Tips

  122. Pingback: car locksmith

  123. Pingback: cool android apps may 2014

  124. Pingback: ucuz hosting

  125. Pingback: The RemarkaMobile Business

  126. Pingback: Restore My Vision Today

  127. Pingback: werbung

  128. Pingback: Ontario

  129. Pingback: beachbody shake

  130. Pingback: football

  131. Pingback: Best online auction sites

  132. Pingback: los angeles traffic attorneys 1.4M

  133. Pingback: renta de autos en cancun

  134. Pingback: check this

  135. Pingback: wooden made

  136. Pingback: the best forex robot

  137. Pingback: Northern Virginia Dryer Vent Cleaning

  138. Pingback: Computational Science and Engineering

  139. Pingback: GNLD moisturizing hand bodylotion

  140. Pingback: renta de autos en cancun

  141. Pingback: ganesh chaturthi songs

  142. Pingback: irvine auto repair

  143. Pingback: my blogs

  144. Pingback: Mayweather vs Maidana 2

  145. Pingback: renta de autos en cancun

  146. Pingback: in here

  147. Pingback: mazda trucks

  148. Pingback: my site

  149. Pingback: viagra

  150. Pingback: Porno Filmes

  151. Pingback: Jasa Perbanyak Follower

  152. Pingback: Tambah Instagram Like

  153. Pingback: cialis danger

  154. Pingback: fish oil capsules

  155. Pingback: One little mortgage website that could save you hundreds!

  156. Pingback: bladder cancer cells root cause

  157. Pingback: resources

  158. Pingback: in here

  159. Pingback: info

  160. Pingback: legal highs

Comments are closed.