Whither Liberal Arts?

This is part one in a series on last week’s iPad event. Part 1: Whither Liberal Arts? | Part 2: The Missing “Why” of the iPad | Part 3: The Magical iPad

Steve Jobs closed the January, 2010 introduction of the iPad with this now famous slide:

Steve Jobs and the intersection of technology and the liberal arts

Steve Jobs and the intersection of technology and the liberal arts

His remarks:

The reason that Apple is able to create products like the iPad is because we’ve always tried to be at the intersection of technology and the liberal arts. To be able to get the best of both. To make extremely advanced products from a technology point of view, but also have them be intuitive easy-to-use, fun-to-use, so that they really fit the users. The users don’t have to come to them, they come to the user. And it’s the combination of these two things that I think has let us make the kind of creative products like the iPad.

He repeated the slide the following year, at the iPad 2 launch:

So, I’ve said this before, but I thought it was worth repeating. It’s in Apple’s DNA that technology alone is not enough. That it’s technology married with liberal arts, married with the humanities that yields us the result that makes our hearts sing. And, no where is that more true than in these post-PC devices. And a lot of folks in this tablet market are rushing in and they’re looking at this as the next PC. The hardware and the software are done by different companies, and they’re talking about speeds and feeds just like they did with PCs. And our experience and every bone in our body says that that is not the right approach to this. That these are post PC devices that need to be even easier to use than a PC. They need to be even more intuitive than a PC. And where the software and hardware and the applications need to intertwine in an even more seamless way than they do on a PC. And we think we’re on the right track with this. We think we have the right architecture not just in silicon but in the organization to build these kinds of products. And so I think we stand a pretty good chance at being pretty competitive in this market, and I hope that what you’ve seen today gives you a pretty good feel for that.

This year’s iPad launch also featured a repeat performance, this time of the abstract “values” video that opened WWDC:

The effect could not have been more different.

Jobs second speech – like the second iPad, and like the entire presentation that preceded it – was fuller, more filled out. Apple had launched the iPad in 2010 not quite sure of its place in the universe, but a year later, the vision was clear: it was not that the iPad needed to be better at jobs done by a laptop or smartphone, as Jobs promised in 2010; rather, the iPad was capable of previously unimagined applications that were truly life-changing. To put it another way, the iPad 1 launch featured Pages, a pale imitation of a PC word processor; the iPad 2 launch featured GarageBand, an application that was immensely better on the iPad by virtue of it not being a PC.

Yesterday’s opening, however, gave the opposite impression: of staleness, and ossification.1 Words and illustrations on a canvas, literally replayed, without life, without originality. Perhaps it’s because it was a video instead of the spoken word, but the rest of the presentation was in the same vein. In Jobs’ words, Cook and company were “talking about speeds and feeds just like they did with PCs,” with hardly even a mention of real people, and the very real impact the iPad had already had on so many, and could have on so many more.

After that WWDC keynote, I wrote a glowing endorsement of Tim Cook, titled, aptly enough, Tim Cook is a Great CEO. I spent an extended amount of time on Scott Forstall:

Forstall is, more than anyone on the planet – including Jobs – responsible for the iPhone (for this reason alone I found the potshots taken at Forstall, particularly by Craig Federighi, to be in poor taste). He is an incredible engineer – legend has it he could write, or rewrite, nearly any part of the iOS source code on command, and would routinely do so to win disputes in managerial meetings – and a NEXT man, and the closest thing to a Steve Jobs 2.0.

Yet Cook fired him anyway.

Apple didn’t need another Steve Jobs. The price of individual brilliance is collective friction, and only a founder has the cultural capital to make the elevation of the individual possible. After all, he/she created the culture to begin with!

It’s not unlike a revolutionary movement: typically there is the transcendent leader, surrounded by the true believers. Eventually the leader departs, but the revolutions that endure have an ideology that continues to unite. To be sure, over time said ideology ossifies into rules enforced by a bureaucracy, until a new revolution uproots the old one, but this can take many years, even decades.

Most revolutions, though, don’t make it that far. Usually, when the leader departs, his closest lieutenants scheme and fight for the throne, and the entire movement implodes. This was always my fear for Apple: Steve Jobs was the glue that united a strong, stubborn, and talented company that continually operated under high pressure. What would happen when the glue was gone?

Tim Cook has answered that question: the glue is Apple, and the ideology is design. It is a shared belief system that “No” is more important than “Yes,” that focus is essential to making great products, and that no one individual is essential. Not Steve Jobs, and certainly not Scott Forstall.

Today, my certainty in this declaration is wavering. What is design? How fast does ossification arrive? Why is it that Jony Ive is the sole arbiter? And what about Forstall?

I went back and watched the iPad 1 introductory video, and the relative roles of Ive and Forstall were jarring:

Ive opened and closed the 7 minute and 48 second video, but his total time on screen was only 70 seconds – 15%.

Forstall, on the other hand, featured for a straight 3 minutes and 45 seconds – just about half.

Ive himself all but explained why:

The face of the product is pretty much defined by a single piece of multi-touch glass. And that’s it. There’s no pointing device. There’s isn’t even a single orientation. There’s no up, there’s no down. There’s no right way of holding it. I don’t have to change myself to change the product. It fits me.

Indeed, the first iPad – and all of the iPads that followed – are marvelously designed and manufactured, but the magic is absolutely in the glass, in the software. And that was all Forstall. His opening lines:

We looked at the device and we decided, “Let’s redesign it all. Let’s redesign, reimagine, and rebuild every single app from the ground up specifically for the iPad.” And with this large a display we built apps that aren’t just a little bit better than their smaller counterparts. You get apps that are an order of magnitude more powerful.

Forstall’s enthusiasm and excitement are absolutely tangible, and, quite frankly, in marked contrast to Ive. And so it goes. Meaning and value always rise up through the stack, and as hardware increasingly melts away, it’s software that differentiates, that requires the utmost in care, and the ethos of the liberal arts.

And yet, today it’s Ive who manages that, and iOS 7 is certainly Iveian: it looks beautiful, it demos well, and it absolutely compromises a certain level of intuitiveness and consideration in the pursuit of beauty.

I like iOS 7, particularly its palette, but it is less usable. Almost daily I find myself momentarily stumped about how to proceed or backtrack, and the sparseness of many layouts makes options less obvious. The motion is a neat effect, until the 100th time you see it, or unless it makes you sick. It is more beautiful, but it is less intuitive. In short, it bears the mark of not just the maker of the iMac, but also the maker of the iMac’s mouse.

Beautiful, but usable?

Beautiful, but usable?

It’s telling that Jobs did not say that Apple was at the intersection of technology and design. While any designer will tell you that design is about how it works, not looks, to pretend there isn’t a tension is naive. The liberal arts, though, and the humanities, are literally about people. They are about how they learn and experience the world, and each other. The magic of the first iPad – as noted by Ive in that video – was that people already knew how to use it. And the magic of the iPad today is that people are using it in ways no one could have imagined.

The absolute highlight of the presentation was this video that captured exactly that:

Yet note Cook’s comments at the end:

It’s really an amazing video and each of those scenes has an amazing story behind it. We want to help out customers create even more amazing stories because we know that this is just the beginning for iPad. And so we’ve been busy working on the next generation of iPad.

And thus proceeded the speeds and feeds, and none of the actual stories. How has the iPad changed lives? Why does it exist? Where are the apps that makes these applications possible?

This, then, is my concern: Apple is in great shape, and executing wonderfully. Both new iPads look fantastic, and I want both of them. But I’m already a convert! There are many more customers who don’t yet know that the “computer for the rest of us” exists, and Apple itself doesn’t seem to know how to tell that story.2 Look at the ad previewed in the keynote:

There are no stories, and there are no humans. It’s clever yet abstract, remarking upon what has happened, without a vision for what is now possible. That’s the thing about stories: the best storytellers – like Jobs – are so compelling because they have vision. They see what we don’t see, and they can’t be more excited to tell us about just that.

Does Apple still have vision? Yesterday’s presentation did not, and I wonder just how costly last year’s departure might have been.

  1. To be clear, I loved the video the first time! But that was enough
  2. This is direct contrast to the iPhone event. I was incredibly impressed by the story Apple told about increasing value, not lowering price

455 thoughts on “Whither Liberal Arts?

  1. Pingback: Daily Update: Apple's New iPad Ads, Intel's Missed Opportunity, Rap Genius Fires Co-Founder | stratechery by Ben Thompson

  2. Pingback: who is a periodontist

  3. Pingback: xovilichter

  4. Pingback: Austin divorce lawyer

  5. Pingback: movemynt products

  6. Pingback: hefalimp cardijon

  7. Pingback:

  8. Pingback: prix tadalafil

  9. Pingback: cialis demi vie

  10. Pingback: online slots

  11. Pingback: chicken coop ideas

  12. Pingback: what is linkedin

  13. Pingback: video

  14. Pingback: how to train to last longer in bed

  15. Pingback: cialis soft tabs

  16. Pingback: macarons te koop

  17. Pingback: payday loans online

  18. Pingback: automotive

  19. Pingback: Harry B. Groom

  20. Pingback: goat fucking

  21. Pingback: best wordpress hosting

  22. Pingback: how to get free instagram followers quick and easy

  23. Pingback: penis enlargement pills

  24. Pingback: cialis durata effetto

  25. Pingback: mmpr licensed producers mmpr licensed producers

  26. Pingback: buy youtube likes

  27. Pingback: olie

  28. Pingback: achat cialis en ligne forum

  29. Pingback: lawyer directory

  30. Pingback: xlovecam token

  31. Pingback: Atomizer

  32. Pingback: novelty techpoint

  33. Pingback: Optimax

  34. Pingback: official source

  35. Pingback: Top 100 Songs

  36. Pingback: Robert Shumake

  37. Pingback: Evidence tracker

  38. Pingback: healthy snacks

  39. Pingback: Driving School Torquay

  40. Pingback: thai massage dublin

  41. Pingback: Orlando vacation rentals near disney

  42. Pingback: nature's comfort reviews

  43. Pingback: Sydney escorts

  44. Pingback: Shaahin

  45. Pingback: Shaahin Cheyene

  46. Pingback: attorney

  47. Pingback: kitchens

  48. Pingback: hills home market reviews

  49. Pingback: Kids & Teens

  50. Pingback: Kids & Teens

  51. Pingback: หมอสมหมาย

  52. Pingback: kitchen cupboards

  53. Pingback: frases bonitas

  54. Pingback: kitchen cupboards

  55. Pingback: Charles Floate

  56. Pingback: Photive SOUNDSCAPE 8 Review

  57. Pingback: Richard McArthur Realtor

  58. Pingback: Flight Tickets

  59. Pingback: DIRTY ARMY

  60. Pingback: Richard McArthur Port Orchard

  61. Pingback: Richard McArthur Port Orchard

  62. Pingback: acheter cialis par internet

  63. Pingback: raptor bumper

  64. Pingback: cult education

  65. Pingback: Penis enlargement

  66. Pingback: raleigh wedding videographer

  67. Pingback: brides of ukraine agency

  68. Pingback: buy cheap likes

  69. Pingback: amazing porn site

  70. Pingback: aqui

  71. Pingback: electric bike motor

  72. Pingback: electric bike

  73. Pingback: Madden 15 eBooks

  74. Pingback: salsa en malaga

  75. Pingback: why cant i last longer in bed

  76. Pingback: بفركس شركة

  77. Pingback: emily bronte books

  78. Pingback: dbz full episodes

  79. Pingback: sex sites

  80. Pingback: make money online for free

  81. Pingback: Inner Circle

  82. Pingback: Ceiling Fan Installation

  83. Pingback: Home Improvement

  84. Pingback: Carey Martell

  85. Pingback: Faucet Repair

  86. Pingback: Skip Trowel Texture

  87. Pingback: Knockdown Texture

  88. Pingback: Popcorn Ceiling Removal

  89. Pingback: moved here

  90. Pingback: Process Servers in Illinois

  91. Pingback: Classes

  92. Pingback: youtube mp4

  93. Pingback: benefits of shakeology

  94. Pingback: dryer vent cleaning Mclean

  95. Pingback: Chicago

  96. Pingback: cool android apps june 2014

  97. Pingback: mental guidance

  98. Pingback: kvar

  99. Pingback: restore my vision today reviews

  100. Pingback: Flat Fee MLS

  101. Pingback: werbung

  102. Pingback: Pre-Apporval

  103. Pingback: free classified ad sites

  104. Pingback: donna rv dealer

  105. Pingback: kvar

  106. Pingback: traffic attorneys los angeles 1.5M 10

  107. Pingback: caregiver

  108. Pingback: rosary beads

  109. Pingback: Sir Robert Gordon Menzies Scholar

  110. Pingback: Roy Williams

  111. Pingback: irvine auto repair

  112. Pingback: renta de autos en cancun

  113. Pingback: apkstorm

  114. Pingback: Bee Wild Pest Control

  115. Pingback: renta de autos en cancun

  116. Pingback: vorzeitiger samenerguss

  117. Pingback: Mayweather vs Maidana 2

  118. Pingback: viagra

  119. Pingback: how long does premature ejaculation last

  120. Pingback: Criminal Lawyer

  121. Pingback: Perbanyak Likes Instagram

  122. Pingback: Jual Menambah Follower

  123. Pingback: diabetic issues mellitus procedure producing bladder cancer.

  124. Pingback: fish oil supplements

  125. Pingback: 13 of the hottest mortgage programs out there!

  126. Pingback: One little mortgage website that could save you hundreds!

  127. Pingback: Medical tourism

  128. Pingback: minecraft like games

  129. Pingback: eye insurance

  130. Pingback: my site

  131. Pingback: puffy eyes

  132. Pingback: houses for sale

  133. Pingback: Illinois Process Server

  134. Pingback: 6 easy ways to mess up a home purchase!

  135. Pingback: Viagra Pills

  136. Pingback: Conas molhadas

  137. Pingback: link m88

  138. Pingback: games app

  139. Pingback: viagra

  140. Pingback: Tanja Portolese

  141. Pingback: viagra

  142. Pingback: read more

  143. Pingback: address book birthday

  144. Pingback: nicaragua paginas web

  145. Pingback: tarot reading android

  146. Pingback: presbicia auditiva

  147. Pingback: maxxim racing best trademark name wheels

  148. Pingback: getting a home loan in santa maria

  149. Pingback: learn crochet

  150. Pingback: printing press

  151. Pingback: Chimney Sweep

  152. Pingback: payday loans

  153. Pingback: pirater un compte facebook

  154. Pingback: pirater un compte facebook

  155. Pingback: Lastentarvikkeet

  156. Pingback: Learn How To Make Cash With Instagram

  157. Pingback: jam casio murah

  158. Pingback: assfuck

  159. Pingback: promovare pe internet

  160. Pingback: cheap viagra

  161. Pingback: iphone6

  162. Pingback: Titfuck

  163. Pingback: make money on twitter

  164. Pingback: Make Money Forum

  165. Pingback: superbahis kayit

  166. Pingback: Bodyguard Service

  167. Pingback: bets10

  168. Pingback: Desktop Support

  169. Pingback: planning to pay for college

  170. Pingback: debt planning

  171. Pingback: here

  172. Pingback: bee wild pest control

  173. Pingback: pest control houston review

  174. Pingback: appliance repair in Yonkers

  175. Pingback: Yonkers appliance repair

  176. Pingback: homemade sausage

  177. Pingback: peruse more blog posts from the author

  178. Pingback: Free Trial garcinia cambogia

  179. Pingback: Celebrity Gossip

  180. Pingback: MovieStarPlanet Cheats Tool

  181. Pingback: Reseller pack 2

  182. Pingback: perfume

  183. Pingback: juicy couture outlet

  184. Pingback: Curtain Walls & Parts

  185. Pingback: pussy

  186. Pingback: Cialis

  187. Pingback: Essential Oils

  188. Pingback: mac data recovery guru

  189. Pingback: dive

  190. Pingback: hni databases

  191. Pingback: appliance repair Scottsdale

  192. Pingback: easeus data recovery

  193. Pingback: Free Download Register Software's

  194. Pingback: data recovery wizard

  195. Pingback: easeus data recovery wizard

  196. Pingback: House eviction

  197. Pingback: Workers Compensation Odessa Doctors 

  198. Pingback: modere products

  199. Pingback: Glendale appliance repair

  200. Pingback: twerking gif

  201. Pingback: viagra online

  202. Pingback: cash for gold

  203. Pingback: cheap viagra

  204. Pingback: Buckeye appliance repair

  205. Pingback: cheap viagra

  206. Pingback: slot machine games online

  207. Pingback: viagra

  208. Pingback: sex

  209. Pingback: pretoria carpet cleaning

  210. Pingback: Baltasar sanchez haz

  211. Pingback: Decentralized, open-source, next-gen finance and betting protocol

  212. Pingback: field hockey

  213. Pingback: stop arguing

  214. Pingback: Millions of dollars paid out

  215. Pingback: izmir escort

  216. Pingback: Denver DUI Lawyers

  217. Pingback: m?s informaci?n

  218. Pingback:

  219. Pingback: putas tetonas

  220. Pingback: buy xenical

  221. Pingback: click here

  222. Pingback: click here

  223. Pingback: click here

  224. Pingback: click here

  225. Pingback: workbook for wheelock's latin

  226. Pingback: instant tax solutions reviews

  227. Pingback: oxycontin without prescription

  228. Pingback: Firma adresser

  229. Pingback: caramoan tour

  230. Pingback: Home Doing Online Jobs

  231. Pingback: Anik Singal

  232. Pingback: buy adipex

  233. Pingback: inversé du 118000

  234. Pingback: blackhatworld

  235. Pingback: complementos online

  236. Pingback: continue reading review

  237. Pingback: BTCRumor - Rumors about bitcoin

  238. Pingback: notepad bluebox

  239. Pingback: used cars in dubai united arab emirates

  240. Pingback: Glass Replacement in Tempe

  241. Pingback: Whatsapp status quotes

  242. Pingback: this page

  243. Pingback: CPCS Answers

  244. Pingback: Break

  245. Pingback: locksmiths Nottingham

  246. Pingback: webshop

  247. Pingback: tarot gratis

  248. Pingback: abc chauffeurs

  249. Pingback: skin mask

  250. Pingback: reviews affordable pups

  251. Pingback: Bee Wild Pest Control

  252. Pingback: review is here

  253. Pingback: ??? ???? ???? ???? 1 ??? 1 ????? ?????

  254. Pingback: maidana vs mayweather 2 live stream

  255. Pingback: MOL account activation

  256. Pingback: best pay day loans

  257. Pingback: Free Online Game

  258. Pingback: Marijuana seeds canada

  259. Pingback: Exterminator Service Houston Texas

  260. Pingback: Devvon Terrell I Like It Ft Kazzie Pop Video Is Crazy

  261. Pingback: Mr. Kuek

  262. Pingback: epub gratis

  263. Pingback: FanDuel Promo Code

  264. Pingback: Pest Control Service in Richmond Tx

  265. Pingback: teen dating

  266. Pingback: emotional intelligence training

  267. Pingback: dinner cruises

  268. Pingback: air conditioning sherman oaks

  269. Pingback: treadmill advice

  270. Pingback: play free slots online

  271. Pingback: yesil kahve

  272. Pingback: kurti

  273. Pingback: vape

  274. Pingback: Cheap protein

  275. Pingback: wedding garlands

  276. Pingback: wedding Photographer

  277. Pingback: cardiff commercial property

  278. Pingback: detox and alcohol

  279. Pingback: perimeter intrusion detection system

  280. Pingback: bail bonds orange county

  281. Pingback: Winchester sunroom

  282. Pingback: sunroom winchester

  283. Pingback: nether hack

  284. Pingback: sunroom hagerstown

  285. Pingback: sunroom springfield

  286. Pingback: yorktown sunroom

  287. Pingback: online slot games for free

  288. Pingback: Free C#.NET Projects

  289. Pingback: sewa elf surabaya murah

  290. Pingback: leather leggings

  291. Pingback: macchina fotografica reflex consigli construction

  292. Pingback: buy hydrocodone online

  293. Pingback: buy cialis

  294. Pingback: buy tramadol

  295. Pingback: Belkin iPad Case

  296. Pingback: how to eliminate premature ejaculation

  297. Pingback: cialis

  298. Pingback: bdoutdoors

  299. Pingback: code promo

  300. Pingback: kitchen fitters north yorkshire

  301. Pingback: bet sports

  302. Pingback: campaign

  303. Pingback: free sex

  304. Pingback: bloodydecks

  305. Pingback: articles

  306. Pingback: banana blue

  307. Pingback: Cash in for Coins for $$$-Advertise you website to thousands

  308. Pingback: xlovecam t�l�charger g�n�rateur de cl�

  309. Pingback: divorce lawyers

  310. Pingback: pussy

  311. Pingback: Shop Beauty Products

  312. Pingback: Witherspoon Locksmith

  313. Pingback: gambling

  314. Pingback: How Much Mortgage Can I Get

  315. Pingback: Slutty Marketing Porn

  316. Pingback: join the illuminati

  317. Pingback: Elephant Art

  318. Pingback: marketing perth

  319. Pingback: Viagra

  320. Pingback: Aspergers Quiz

  321. Pingback: awakening kundalini meditation

  322. Pingback: Cialis

  323. Pingback: penis enlargement

  324. Pingback: best seo company australia

  325. Pingback: Criminal Lawyer Toronto

  326. Pingback: Daniel Schlosberg

  327. Pingback: new iphone 5c cases

  328. Pingback: forex

  329. Pingback: search engine optimisation perth

  330. Pingback: webdesign perth

  331. Pingback: leading seo companies

  332. Pingback: loyal 9 reviews

  333. Pingback: cerrajeris urgente murcia

  334. Pingback: App Marketing

  335. Pingback: Home Printing Business Opportunities

  336. Pingback: best weight loss diet

  337. Pingback: Mobile spa

  338. Pingback: cook book

  339. Pingback: arkitekter

  340. Pingback: Ways to Get Netflix without a Credit Card

  341. Pingback: Lilia

  342. Pingback: DC Movers

  343. Pingback: online Broker

  344. Pingback: Farmacia online

  345. Pingback: cerebral palsy disability types

  346. Pingback: bisnis tas wanita

  347. Pingback: dr. gerald buchoff

  348. Pingback: plymouth bjj

  349. Pingback: hecigarette review

  350. Pingback: house financing

  351. Pingback: Camilo Concha

  352. Pingback: Vickie

  353. Pingback: Walking Sticks

  354. Pingback: buy soundcloud plays and downloads package

  355. Pingback: lose weight fast

  356. Pingback: criminal attorney

  357. Pingback: zidalo

  358. Pingback: advertising for free

  359. Pingback: code promo delamaison

  360. Pingback: numéro de téléphone particulier

  361. Pingback: Caller ID Dip Revenue

  362. Pingback: bajar de peso alcachofa de laon

  363. Pingback: Gambling

  364. Pingback: Hacking Tutorials

  365. Pingback: download bluestacks

  366. Pingback: swap games

  367. Pingback: Episode 017: Let’s End it There | Exponent

  368. Pingback: descuentos peru

  369. Pingback: Elizabeth Hapner

  370. Pingback: hearthstone arena guide

  371. Pingback: Hack Facebook Account

  372. Pingback: elevator data cable

  373. Pingback: olej kokosowy sklep

  374. Pingback: kancleria prawna zabrze

  375. Pingback: kable grzejne

  376. Pingback: odzywki na mase

  377. Pingback: donice drewniane

  378. Pingback: posciel bawelniana

  379. Pingback: Appliance repair service center

  380. Pingback: blog 40+

  381. Pingback: boost my likes

  382. Pingback: iva

  383. Pingback: quickextenderpro

  384. Pingback: Home repair service

  385. Pingback: Appliance repair service center

  386. Pingback: sobre Ivan Bedia Garcia

  387. Pingback: The Appliance repair service center

  388. Pingback: Great Flash fiction literary journal

  389. Pingback: gum ball machines

  390. Pingback: Washer repair

  391. Pingback: startup videos

  392. Pingback: minecraft online

  393. Pingback: commonwealth towers psf

  394. Pingback: custom TradeStation consulting

  395. Pingback: Cerrajeros Alicante

  396. Pingback: zespól muzyczny wroclaw

  397. Pingback: pay day loans

  398. Pingback: easy 100 reviews

  399. Pingback: vending machines australia

  400. Pingback: cheap orange beach beach Rentals

  401. Pingback: free porn

  402. Pingback: TShirts

  403. Pingback: pages jaunes

  404. Pingback: free loans

  405. Pingback: ????? ????

  406. Pingback: videos

  407. Pingback: person’s

  408. Pingback: seo uzmanı

  409. Pingback: free bulk email

  410. Pingback: samaa tv live

  411. Pingback: garden shed plans

  412. Pingback: buy instagram likes

  413. Pingback:

  414. Pingback: home remedies for hair bumps on face

  415. Pingback: GreenSmoke e-cigarettes

  416. Pingback:

  417. Pingback: porn for free

  418. Pingback: Livejasmin Hack

  419. Pingback: income

  420. Pingback: Bob Marley

  421. Pingback: watches nike

  422. Pingback: tangkas meja darat

  423. Pingback: Miami Limo

  424. Pingback: Dubia Roaches

  425. Pingback: coconut water

  426. Pingback: cosmetica natural online

  427. Pingback: LAX Car Service

  428. Pingback: Interlink

  429. Pingback: toy schnauzer puppies for sale

  430. Pingback: buy seo

  431. Pingback: orsign double floor spring orfs 8400

  432. Pingback: online flashcards

  433. Pingback: buy seo

  434. Pingback: newport beach

  435. Pingback: newport beach

  436. Pingback: Newport Beach

  437. Pingback: Kacey Warsing

  438. Pingback: personal trainer

  439. Pingback: betboo

  440. Pingback: buy forever living products online

  441. Pingback: sprawdz sam

  442. Pingback: need help moving furniture

  443. Pingback: binary options trading

  444. Pingback: 360 degrees video

  445. Pingback: mtv jersey shore

  446. Pingback: luxury aircraft solutions private jet charters

  447. Pingback: Black light minigolf

  448. Pingback: Online Signature

  449. Pingback: betboo

  450. Pingback: vince stanzione

  451. Pingback: License

  452. Pingback: süperbahis

  453. Pingback: betboo

  454. Pingback: betboo

  455. Pingback: betboo

Comments are closed.