stratechery
stratechery

The Stages of Newspapers’ Decline

The second-most common objection to FiveThirtyEight and the End of Average was along these lines:

That’s very true; those same people – and there are a lot of them – didn’t read the news in a newspaper either. Instead they read the Style section, or Sports, the comics or Dear Abby. It doesn’t really matter though – the same principle of the best killing the average still applies. What is Buzzfeed if not funnies for grownups?

Even that, though, undersells what is happening: it’s not only that the Internet lets you find the objectively best content, but that it also lets you find the subjectively best content based on your interests.

To return to the same Columbia Journalism Review article I quoted in the last post:

But the control of distribution that was so profitable IRL hasn’t ended online. It just moved, passing from newspapers, TV stations, and the post office to the companies in Andreessen’s portfolio, which happen to have zero cost of content: Google, Facebook, and Twitter (plus the ISPs).

Google’s gross profit margins were 57 percent last year and Facebook’s were 76 percent, which is just bananas. Gannett at the peak of its labor-cutting and advertiser-milking could never have dreamed of those kinds of margins.

Google has 67 percent of the search market. It alone hauls in 41 percent of all online advertising in the entire country.

And why shouldn’t it? The entire premise of Google is that it finds exactly what I am looking for. The potential of Twitter is that it can be perfectly tailored to my interests. A newspaper designed to appeal to the largest cross-section of people with a bundle that includes everything from international news to the horoscope is much, much less likely to have exactly what I’m looking for, and only a small percentage of what it has will be close.

It’s interesting to map the demise of newspapers against the evolution of communication on the Internet:

  • Stage 1 was simply moving offline content online. This let anyone anywhere access the objectively best, like the New York Times. This decimated a lot of local newspapers, like the Wisconsin State Journal (per my last post)
  • Stage 2 was the introduction of user-generated content broadly, and social specifically. This dramatically increased the range of content available, even as it made it easier to find content subjectively better for any one person. This is when even the objectively best newspapers really started to feel the pain
  • Stage 3 is the mobile and contextual stage, highlighted by the rise in messaging. This is about delivering content that is not just personalized but contextually appropriate to my specific situation. What chance does an industry based on broad reach and the idea of daily editions have?

In case you’re wondering, the most-common objection to FiveThirtyEight and the End of Average was that I didn’t address the demise in advertising. That was intentional; while I plan on talking business models – and it’s an important topic – I think that people in the news industry are too quick to attribute their problems to ads, and too slow to understand how incompatible the Internet is with their definition of a newspaper. Newspapers may be screwed, but we can’t start fixing news until we understand what we’re trying to save, and what is simply a relic.

546 thoughts on “The Stages of Newspapers’ Decline

  1. I like your juxtaposition of newspapers and news. I think the Internet also transforms news to subjectively best, opinionated content by individuals that we can actually relate to.

  2. Pingback: carbid kopen

  3. Pingback: mobile locksmith houston

  4. Pingback: elder-scrolls-online-hack

  5. Pingback: lol boost

  6. Pingback: hefalimp cardijon

  7. Pingback: water damage restoration houston

  8. Pingback: cialis 5mg pas cher

  9. Pingback: their explanation

  10. Pingback: best online slots

  11. Pingback: cialis 5 mg comprimГ© pelliculГ© boГ®te de 28

  12. Pingback: learn more,

  13. Pingback: cialis generic canada

  14. Pingback: apple products

  15. Pingback: macarons online bestellen

  16. Pingback: how to make it last longer in bed

  17. Pingback: payday loans for bad credit

  18. Pingback: cialis 5 mg prezzi

  19. Pingback: automotive

  20. Pingback: Education

  21. Pingback: cialis 20mg prix pharmacie

  22. Pingback: useful

  23. Pingback: good

  24. Pingback: superkarts.info

  25. Pingback: makerquest.org

  26. Pingback: mybailhotline.info

  27. Pingback: tecnosanagustin.info

  28. Pingback: video bugil

  29. Pingback: btcbible.info

  30. Pingback: buy youtube promotion

  31. Pingback: cialis 5 mg daily

  32. Pingback: penis enlargement pills

  33. Pingback: yogaitalia.info

  34. Pingback: mmpr licensed producers mmpr licensed producers

  35. Pingback: gasde.info

  36. Pingback: pieterwellens.info

  37. Pingback: meganisi.info

  38. Pingback: porn

  39. Pingback: lawyer

  40. Pingback: mozi-q.info

  41. Pingback: cialis original prix

  42. Pingback: uproarpr.info

  43. Pingback: e-cig

  44. Pingback: xlovecam free tokens

  45. Pingback: sonos connect amp

  46. Pingback: Health

  47. Pingback: tomturbo.info

  48. Pingback: beds online

  49. Pingback: novelty techpoint

  50. Pingback: gestong.info

  51. Pingback: Robert Shumake

  52. Pingback: browse around

  53. Pingback: Optimax

  54. Pingback: New Songs 2014

  55. Pingback: Slendera

  56. Pingback: dotmonster.info

  57. Pingback: thai massage dublin

  58. Pingback: sick of law suits

  59. Pingback: Driving School Paignton

  60. Pingback: thai massage dublin

  61. Pingback: roz grammes

  62. Pingback: Bitcoin casino

  63. Pingback: Shaahin Cheyene

  64. Pingback: Penis enlargement

  65. Pingback: TN

  66. Pingback: business

  67. Pingback: Telecharger les Sims 4

  68. Pingback: cupboards

  69. Pingback: Kids & Teens

  70. Pingback: porn

  71. Pingback: kitchen cupboards

  72. Pingback: Charles Floate

  73. Pingback: Flight Tickets

  74. Pingback: Richard McArthur Real Estate

  75. Pingback: Photive SOUNDSCAPE 8 Review

  76. Pingback: Richard McArthur Realtor

  77. Pingback: teenagemodelingagencies

  78. Pingback: best wireless speakers

  79. Pingback: Richard McArthur Washington

  80. Pingback: Richard McArthur Real Estate

  81. Pingback: camilo concha

  82. Pingback: cult

  83. Pingback: brides of ukraine

  84. Pingback: cupones de descuento

  85. Pingback: cult education

  86. Pingback: achat cialis 10mg

  87. Pingback: buy facebook likes

  88. Pingback: Viagra

  89. Pingback: Crime News

  90. Pingback: web

  91. Pingback: bay area garage door

  92. Pingback: juegos gratis

  93. Pingback: compartilo

  94. Pingback: edward maldonado

  95. Pingback: bay area overhead door

  96. Pingback: desensitizing creams for premature ejaculation reviews

  97. Pingback: stresser

  98. Pingback: is online dating destroying love

  99. Pingback: doc love online dating

  100. Pingback: how to find success in online dating

  101. Pingback: M88

  102. Pingback: dbz guitars

  103. Pingback: payday loans

  104. Pingback: is online dating destroyin

  105. Pingback: sex xxx

  106. Pingback: bus tours to new york from charlottetown

  107. Pingback: Empower Network Affiliate

  108. Pingback: ford raptor parts

  109. Pingback: Mortgage company

  110. Pingback: sacred geometry

  111. Pingback: Home Improvement

  112. Pingback: Drywall Finishing

  113. Pingback: Faucet Repair

  114. Pingback: bus tours to new york city

  115. Pingback: just click the next document

  116. Pingback: Popcorn Ceiling Removal

  117. Pingback: Knockdown Texture

  118. Pingback: Cord Blood

  119. Pingback: Albuquerque Appliance Repair

  120. Pingback: custom wordpress theme design

  121. Pingback: Arlington VA dryer vent cleaning

  122. Pingback: Northern Virginia Dryer Vent Cleaning

  123. Pingback: Top hair styles

  124. Pingback: cool android apps ideas

  125. Pingback: lost car keys

  126. Pingback: writing

  127. Pingback: Flat Fee MLS Realtor IL

  128. Pingback: ningcai

  129. Pingback: werbung

  130. Pingback: football

  131. Pingback: Burlington

  132. Pingback: los angeles traffic ticket lawyer

  133. Pingback: renta de autos en cancun

  134. Pingback: rosary beads

  135. Pingback: the best forex robot

  136. Pingback: E-vitamiini

  137. Pingback: irvine auto repair

  138. Pingback: Honey Bee Removal Kingwood Texas

  139. Pingback: Music & Audio apps

  140. Pingback: renta de autos en cancun

  141. Pingback: http://www.law.fsu.edu/library/flsupct/91325/op-91325.pdf

  142. Pingback: Menambah Instagram Follower

  143. Pingback: Service Tambah Follower

  144. Pingback: fish oil supplements

  145. Pingback: Assistir Filmes

  146. Pingback: desensitizing cream for premature ejaculation

  147. Pingback: bladder cancer information updates on lawsuits and lawsuits versus Actos.

  148. Pingback: Criminal Lawyer

  149. Pingback: Afford a Home with these tips...

  150. Pingback: eye doctors that take medicaid

  151. Pingback: advertise property for sale

  152. Pingback: click here

  153. Pingback: cost of eye exam

  154. Pingback: 32 weken zwanger

  155. Pingback: Afford a Home with these tips...

  156. Pingback: games app

  157. Pingback: Viagra

  158. Pingback: Payday loans

  159. Pingback: Montgomery AL For Sale By Owner

  160. Pingback: Montgomery AL For Sale By Owner

  161. Pingback: Tabitha Hoops

  162. Pingback: Domitila Dorge

  163. Pingback: YOGA HK

  164. Pingback: apartamentos lisboa

  165. Pingback: read more

  166. Pingback: viagra

  167. Pingback: internet address password book

  168. Pingback: labor day poems

  169. Pingback: android apps

  170. Pingback: tadalafil india

  171. Pingback: cartoons wallpapers

  172. Pingback: deep cleansing facial

  173. Pingback: www.hotclick.co.uk

  174. Pingback: destiny horoscope

  175. Pingback: blend auto racing tires for promotion

  176. Pingback: pirater un compte facebook

  177. Pingback: free mp3's

  178. Pingback: gordas en pasarela

  179. Pingback: santa maria real estate

  180. Pingback: crochet tutorial

  181. Pingback: Bee Wild Pest Control

  182. Pingback: fantasy novels for teens

  183. Pingback: crossfit equipment package

  184. Pingback: pirater un compte facebook

  185. Pingback: Viagra

  186. Pingback: Whatsapp Hack

  187. Pingback: dwi book

  188. Pingback: cialis cheap

  189. Pingback: jam tangan original

  190. Pingback: iphone6

  191. Pingback: optimizare seo

  192. Pingback: cheap viagra

  193. Pingback: Incest

  194. Pingback: assfuck

  195. Pingback: eset nod32 antivirus 4 keys

  196. Pingback: PTCSmarty

  197. Pingback: superbahis kayit

  198. Pingback: Nike Coupon Code

  199. Pingback: Hire

  200. Pingback: pest control houston review

  201. Pingback: bee wild pest control

  202. Pingback: appliance repair near Yonkers NY

  203. Pingback: appliance repair Yonkers NY

  204. Pingback: appliance repair Manhattan

  205. Pingback: Whatsapp status sad

  206. Pingback: cialis pour diabete

  207. Pingback: dr oz free trial garcinia cambogia

  208. Pingback: take a peek at this newly updated internet site

  209. Pingback: ???????? Domain Names

  210. Pingback: MovieStarPlanet Cheats Tool

  211. Pingback: partition recovery mac

  212. Pingback: openappmkt

  213. Pingback: Cialis

  214. Pingback: trash recovery mac

  215. Pingback: easeus data recovery

  216. Pingback: Guitar Licks You’ll Love - “Stand By Me” on Guitar

  217. Pingback: easy divers

  218. Pingback: Chandler appliance repair

  219. Pingback: mac os x file recovery

  220. Pingback: Free Download Games

  221. Pingback: Scottsdale appliance repair

  222. Pingback: House eviction

  223. Pingback: houston Commercial Cleaning

  224. Pingback: modere shifting retail

  225. Pingback: nursing

  226. Pingback: Baltasar sanchez haz

  227. Pingback: twerking

  228. Pingback: appliance repair Goodyear

  229. Pingback: viagra online

  230. Pingback: sex

  231. Pingback: buy valium

  232. Pingback: buy tramadol

  233. Pingback: ambien online

  234. Pingback: oxycontin without prescription

  235. Pingback: Provably fair Bitcoin betting with trustless escrow

  236. Pingback: Denver DUI Attorney

  237. Pingback: escort izmir

  238. Pingback: soccer

  239. Pingback: buy adderall

  240. Pingback: buy tramadol

  241. Pingback: Annuaire des particuliers

  242. Pingback: LabIwYCk

  243. Pingback: rjswordprocessing

  244. Pingback: Blackhatgalaxy

  245. Pingback: putas de calle

  246. Pingback: click aqu?

  247. Pingback: study guide captains courageous

  248. Pingback: Annuaire des particuliers

  249. Pingback: cracked seo tools

  250. Pingback: look these up

  251. Pingback: film izle

  252. Pingback: puppy cages

  253. Pingback: cash for gold

  254. Pingback: notepad bluebox

  255. Pingback: voyage de noce

  256. Pingback: BTCRumor - Bitcoin News,Tools and Stats

  257. Pingback: NHL

  258. Pingback: Glass Replacement in Tempe

  259. Pingback: bookmarks

  260. Pingback: sex

  261. Pingback: CPCS Answers

  262. Pingback: website design in perth

  263. Pingback: caramoan tour

  264. Pingback: plum lipstick

  265. Pingback: car locksmith in Ann Arbor

  266. Pingback: Live sex

  267. Pingback: dead sea mud mask

  268. Pingback: ?????? ???? 3 ??????

  269. Pingback: Pest Control Houston Texas

  270. Pingback: web design perth australia

  271. Pingback: tinder sprueche

  272. Pingback: maidana vs mayweather 2 showtime ppv live stream

  273. Pingback: MOL account free

  274. Pingback: Exterminator Service Houston Texas

  275. Pingback: FanDuel Promo Code

  276. Pingback: Desmond Kuek

  277. Pingback: hbos

  278. Pingback: prix du cialis en belgique

  279. Pingback: teen dating

  280. Pingback: payday loans

  281. Pingback: furniture store

  282. Pingback: dinner cruises

  283. Pingback: lehnga design in delhi

  284. Pingback: Gheata Carbonica

  285. Pingback: air conditioning sherman oaks

  286. Pingback: glass

  287. Pingback: Chicago criminal attorney

  288. Pingback: personalised wedding chocolates

  289. Pingback: Sydney Wedding Photography

  290. Pingback: houses cardiff

  291. Pingback: WordPress Themes

  292. Pingback: germantown sunroom

  293. Pingback: sunrise detox center

  294. Pingback: bail bonds orange county

  295. Pingback: largo sunroom

  296. Pingback: slots games online

  297. Pingback: nether hack

  298. Pingback: north richland hills property

  299. Pingback: sewa elf surabaya

  300. Pingback: wine deals

  301. Pingback: Plus size leggings

  302. Pingback: gold ira companies review

  303. Pingback: buy tramadol

  304. Pingback: buy ativan

  305. Pingback: largo sunroom

  306. Pingback: Colusa Criminal Defense Attorney

  307. Pingback: sunroom alexandria

  308. Pingback: centreville sunroom

  309. Pingback: Cath Kidston iPad Cover

  310. Pingback: Sinisterly - Hackforums Witza Database

  311. Pingback: Lettings agent surbiton

  312. Pingback: code promo

  313. Pingback: sunroom largo

  314. Pingback: code promo modz

  315. Pingback: Cleaners in glasgow

  316. Pingback: fishing reports

  317. Pingback: kitchen fitters chesterfield

  318. Pingback: live sex

  319. Pingback: articles

  320. Pingback: banana blue

  321. Pingback: Sign-up and wait for the party!!

  322. Pingback: cialis

  323. Pingback: divorce lawyer in maryland

  324. Pingback: fishing news

  325. Pingback: tits

  326. Pingback: locksmith Farmington Hills

  327. Pingback: How Much Mortgage Can I Get

  328. Pingback: c.o.p.s.

  329. Pingback: facebook group posting problems

  330. Pingback: website designers perth

  331. Pingback: Aspergers Quiz

  332. Pingback: simply meditation cd

  333. Pingback: Aspergers

  334. Pingback: sex

  335. Pingback: Aspergers

  336. Pingback: Cialis

  337. Pingback: perth web designer

  338. Pingback: payday loans

  339. Pingback: Viagraaustraliaau

  340. Pingback: penis enlargement

  341. Pingback: 5c color case

  342. Pingback: Chicago

  343. Pingback: web designer perth

  344. Pingback: trading investments

  345. Pingback: seo service perth

  346. Pingback: affordable local seo services

  347. Pingback: xylitol gum

  348. Pingback: meditate to music

  349. Pingback: loyal 9 reviews

  350. Pingback: wedding photography

  351. Pingback: App Videos

  352. Pingback: Viagra

  353. Pingback: WholesalePrivate Label Rights Products

  354. Pingback: Chung cu An Bình

  355. Pingback: food recipes

  356. Pingback: more info

  357. Pingback: wilnel verdu

  358. Pingback: weight loss food

  359. Pingback: get plays on soundcloud

  360. Pingback: hecigarette review

  361. Pingback: Sheila

  362. Pingback: Real artist promotion

  363. Pingback: property finance

  364. Pingback: cavaleiros do zodiaco

  365. Pingback: Camilo Concha

  366. Pingback: Gwinnett Web Design

  367. Pingback: trail gear

  368. Pingback: pulseras de gomitas con telar

  369. Pingback: arkitekter

  370. Pingback: plymouth bjj

  371. Pingback: dr. gerald buchoff

  372. Pingback: buy soundcloud plays uk

  373. Pingback: Charlie

  374. Pingback: Canes

  375. Pingback: lose weight

  376. Pingback: code promo sarenza

  377. Pingback: Pomsky

  378. Pingback: criminal attorney

  379. Pingback: numéro de téléphone particulier

  380. Pingback: Get Disability Benefits

  381. Pingback: Call Center VOIP

  382. Pingback: esta web sobre la alcachofa de laon

  383. Pingback: Hacking Tutorials

  384. Pingback: xlovecam online

  385. Pingback: maryland divorce lawyers

  386. Pingback: download bluestacks app player

  387. Pingback: beginner guide

  388. Pingback: descuentos

  389. Pingback: proair hfa 90 mcg inhaler

  390. Pingback: hearthstone arena guide

  391. Pingback: click here

  392. Pingback: Web Development & Optimization

  393. Pingback: olej aragonowy sklep

  394. Pingback: biuro rachunkowe zabrze

  395. Pingback: autobahnvignette 2014

  396. Pingback: essential oils

  397. Pingback: Appliance repair service

  398. Pingback: code nnippet gallery

  399. Pingback: stem cell preservation

  400. Pingback: Buy Real Likes

  401. Pingback: quickextenderpro

  402. Pingback: The Appliance repairman

  403. Pingback: Awesome Self publishing blog

  404. Pingback: quickextenderpro

  405. Pingback: Dryer Service

  406. Pingback: startup videos

  407. Pingback: free minecraft

  408. Pingback: Surprise Appliance Repair

  409. Pingback: Appliance repair Mesa

  410. Pingback: Going Here

  411. Pingback: free diet pills

  412. Pingback: ballet videos

  413. Pingback: earn money fast

  414. Pingback: satel

  415. Pingback: Street Jumpers

  416. Pingback: epoxy garage floor coatings fort collins

  417. Pingback: cheap Gulf Shores Vacation Rentals

  418. Pingback: pages blanches

  419. Pingback: tuppersex

  420. Pingback: Guia de negocios

  421. Pingback: זילכה שירלי

  422. Pingback: ????? ????

  423. Pingback: cleaning company

  424. Pingback: arkitekter kobenhavn

  425. Pingback: seo uzmanı

  426. Pingback: most entrepreneurs

  427. Pingback: ecigarette review

  428. Pingback: buy instagram likes

  429. Pingback: e-cigarette-shop

  430. Pingback: Find local personal injury attorney listings

  431. Pingback: garden shed plans

  432. Pingback: samaa news anchor

  433. Pingback: logo design service

  434. Pingback: stopthestresstoday.com/contact

  435. Pingback: gay porn

  436. Pingback: Guia de negocios

  437. Pingback: bumps when shaving

  438. Pingback: stopthestresstoday.com/about-me

  439. Pingback: Livejasmin Hack no survey no password

  440. Pingback: Family Law

  441. Pingback: Find the Best

  442. Pingback: money free

  443. Pingback: Patriot Rooter

  444. Pingback: mcclung roofing fort worth

  445. Pingback: sfi affiliate

  446. Pingback: sunglasses women

  447. Pingback: Miami Limo

  448. Pingback: cosmetica organica online

  449. Pingback: agenbolatangkas

  450. Pingback: Dubia Roaches

  451. Pingback: Newport Beach

  452. Pingback: newport beach

  453. Pingback: agence digitale

  454. Pingback: Charis Nasr

  455. Pingback: buy seo uk

  456. Pingback: Online ged classes

  457. Pingback: süperbahis

  458. Pingback: Wigs Denver

  459. Pingback: newport beach

  460. Pingback: betboo

  461. Pingback: drysol deodorant

  462. Pingback: Tampa moving services

  463. Pingback: forever living products clean 9 program

  464. Pingback: testy kompetencji - hr24.com.pl

  465. Pingback: filtros de agua

  466. Pingback: drysol reviews

  467. Pingback: betboo

  468. Pingback: njbzmy

  469. Pingback: event photography

  470. Pingback: Miniature golf guide

  471. Pingback: hugh jackman wiki

  472. Pingback: luxury aero

  473. Pingback: hepsibahis

  474. Pingback: web design dallas

  475. Pingback: betboo

  476. Pingback: betboo

  477. Pingback: turf supplier newcastle

  478. Pingback: atms for hire

  479. Pingback: jaipur property

  480. Pingback: jobs

  481. Pingback: sell business

  482. Pingback: abacus

  483. Pingback: West Bloomfield locksmith

  484. Pingback: PATENT LAW

  485. Pingback: Directory

  486. Pingback: WP Profit Builder Bonuses

  487. Pingback: locksmiths in West Bloomfield

  488. Pingback: Aprender idiomas en linea

  489. Pingback: hard money austin

  490. Pingback: ganool

  491. Pingback: prediction baby gender

  492. Pingback: diode pumped solid state laser

  493. Pingback: devis déménagement

  494. Pingback: Property Management

  495. Pingback: Interior Painters

  496. Pingback: Patriot Rooter

  497. Pingback: sub zero service code ec

  498. Pingback: This Site

  499. Pingback: xp windows recovery raid linux

  500. Pingback: restaurant to let in london

  501. Pingback: logiciel devis facture

  502. Pingback: M88

  503. Pingback: Martial

  504. Pingback: eggs with surprise

  505. Pingback: agencja nieruchomosci szczecin

  506. Pingback: osiedle kolo Kartuz

  507. Pingback: Twitter unfollowers tool

  508. Pingback: astrologer

  509. Pingback: dieta con la alcahofa de laon

  510. Pingback: ashley outlet Houston

  511. Pingback: canary islands property

  512. Pingback: pc deals reddit

  513. Pingback: Joe Pojman

  514. Pingback: buy fifa 15 coins

  515. Pingback: comparatif assurance vie

  516. Pingback: Garage door repair Denver CO

  517. Pingback: Ricker Construction - Snow Removal and Excavation Services in Harrisburg PA

  518. Pingback: jiffy lube oil change coupons

  519. Pingback: caralhos gigantes

  520. Pingback: his comment is here

  521. Pingback: kangen water machine

  522. Pingback: locksmiths in Redford

  523. Pingback: ejacultion precoce

  524. Pingback: larina igraonica

  525. Pingback: larin chat

  526. Pingback: precoce comment faire

  527. Pingback: retarder lejaculation

  528. Pingback: ceiling fans

  529. Pingback: loan

  530. Pingback: sypialnia

  531. Pingback: bank owned homes

  532. Pingback: logo

  533. Pingback: I love you

  534. Pingback: event space

  535. Pingback: Law Book Store

  536. Pingback: ejacultion precoce

  537. Pingback: Ocean Isle Wedding Photographer

  538. Pingback: ejacultion precoce

  539. Pingback: bob nokley

  540. Pingback: egg yolk

  541. Pingback: spy

  542. Pingback: It learning

  543. Pingback: Real Estate

  544. Pingback: Tip

  545. Pingback: coaching for competition

  546. Pingback: epic fails

Join the Conversation